| 100% | CHURN | 5 | Make butter the old-fashioned way |
| 77% | EARN | 4 | Make money the old-fashioned way |
| 66% | EARN | 4 | "They make money the old-fashioned way. They ___ it" (old ad slogan) |
| 66% | EARN | 4 | "They make money the old-fashioned way. They ___ it" (1980s ad slogan) |
| 65% | CHATEAULAFEET | 13 | French wine made the old-fashioned way? |
| 61% | EARN | 4 | Acquire "the old fashioned way" |
| 61% | EARNIT | 6 | "The old-fashioned way" to make money, in an old ad |
| 60% | BLEST | 5 | Given benediction, the old-fashioned way |
| 60% | HOE | 3 | Whack weeds the old-fashioned way |
| 59% | HANDWASH | 8 | Launder the old-fashioned way |
| 59% | HANDRUB | 7 | Polish the old-fashioned way |
| 59% | HANDDYE | 7 | Color the old-fashioned way |
| 58% | EARNIT | 6 | How to make money "the old-fashioned way" |
| 58% | EARNIT | 6 | "The old-fashioned way" to make money, per an old Smith Barney ad (2 wds.) |
| 57% | SNAILMAILS | 10 | Sends the old-fashioned way, as a letter |
| 56% | PASTEONATRUESTORY | 17 | Lay out some newspaper copy the old-fashioned way? |
| 54% | DOWDY | 5 | Old-fashioned in the way one dresses |
| 51% | TAINT | 5 | Old fashioned way to say "It isn't" |
| 50% | CHURN | 5 | Old-fashioned device for making butter |
| 50% | EARN | 4 | Acquire "the old-fashioned way" |
| 50% | CHURNED | 7 | Made butter like the Amish |
| 49% | PECAN | 5 | Old Fashioned Butter ___ (Baskin-Robbins flavor) |
| 47% | ACIDWASH | 8 | Make look old, in a way |
| 47% | TABLEHOPS | 9 | Makes the rounds, in a way |
| 47% | GRASPATSTRAWS | 13 | Old fashioned leggings are in -- try for the impossible!? |
| 45% | TIMEY | 5 | Old-___ (from way back in the day) |
| 45% | MISDIAL | 7 | Make the wrong call, in a way |
| 45% | RETRO | 5 | Fashion statement from the good old days |
| 45% | PERMS | 5 | Makes the hair wavy, in a way |
| 44% | MODEST | 6 | Unassuming fashion on the way |