| 100% | ROUGE | 5 | Makeup for the cheeks, in older terminology |
| 59% | ROUGE | 5 | Makeup for the cheeks |
| 57% | ROUGE | 5 | Reddish makeup for the cheeks |
| 47% | AKA | 3 | Oldest sorority in the Divine Nine, for short |
| 46% | ELOHIM | 6 | Name for God in the Old Testament |
| 46% | FLYING | 6 | The 'f' in UFO, old term for a mysterious object |
| 46% | THY | 3 | Old-time word for your, as seen in the Bible |
| 46% | FRONTIERSTANZAQUEST | 19 | Search for poetry in the Old West? [Nissan] |
| 45% | ECO | 3 | In vogue prefix derived from the old Greek name for "household" |
| 45% | DRJ | 3 | Nickname for Erving in the old N.B.A. |
| 44% | MASCARA | 7 | Makeup for the eyelashes |
| 44% | LIPSTICK | 8 | Makeup for the kisser |
| 44% | DRJ | 3 | Nickname for Erving in the old N.B.A.: 2 wds. |
| 43% | THEGREATWAGON | 13 | Old name for the arrangement of the O's in this puzzle |
| 43% | THESEVENOXEN | 12 | Old name for the arrangement of the O's in this puzzle |
| 43% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived for 905 years |
| 43% | JEHOVAH | 7 | Latinized name for god, used in the Old Testament |
| 42% | BLUSH | 5 | Powder for the cheeks |
| 42% | LIPSTICK | 8 | Makeup for the mouth, glossy or matte |
| 42% | ROUGE | 5 | Red powder for the cheeks |
| 42% | ROUGE | 5 | Makeup for cheeks |
| 42% | AVA | 3 | Actress ___ Gardner of old Hollywood fame, known for starring in the hit film "Mogambo" |
| 41% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived for nine hundred and five years |
| 41% | LEA | 3 | Term derived from the Old High German for "clearing" (it's hidden in "clearing," too) |
| 41% | FUSTY | 5 | For the olds, say |
| 40% | VUGS | 4 | Small crystal lined cavities found in rocks whose name comes from the old Cornish for "cave" |
| 40% | LADY | 4 | Old ___ named Ida Mae Maine, whose costume Phil wore for Halloween to prank Claire in the series "Modern Family" |
| 40% | OAST | 4 | Building once essential in drying hops for beer, the oldest of which dates from the 17th century |
| 40% | PLUTO | 5 | What "pizzas" stood for in the old mnemonic "My very eager mother just served us nine pizzas" |
| 39% | FTW | 3 | For the win, in internet slang |