| 100% | SEVEN | 5 | Mantle's retired number |
| 71% | THREE | 5 | Ruth's retired number |
| 67% | SEVEN | 5 | Mantle's jersey number |
| 65% | SEVEN | 5 | Mickey Mantle's number |
| 64% | TEN | 3 | Phil Rizzuto's retired number |
| 64% | TWO | 3 | Derek Jeter's retired number |
| 64% | TEN | 3 | Chipper Jones's retired number |
| 63% | ONE | 3 | Pee Wee Reese's retired number |
| 56% | SIX | 3 | Joe Torre's retired Yankee uniform number |
| 54% | SEVEN | 5 | Mickey Mantle's jersey number |
| 53% | NINE | 4 | Retired number of Roger Maris |
| 52% | TWO | 3 | Retired number of Dodger Tommy Lasorda |
| 52% | MAYS | 4 | Giants' retired number 24 |
| 52% | ORR | 3 | Boston retired his number |
| 51% | SPARKS | 6 | WNBA team that retired Lisa Leslie's number 9 |
| 51% | HEAT | 4 | Miami team that retired Dwyane Wade's number 3 |
| 51% | AROD | 4 | Retired number 13 Yankee slugger, fondly: Hyph. |
| 50% | MUSIAL | 6 | ← Player with this retired number |
| 50% | AARON | 5 | ← Player with this retired number |
| 50% | KOUFAX | 6 | ← Player with this retired number |
| 50% | GEHRIG | 6 | ← Player with this retired number |
| 50% | RUTH | 4 | ← Player with this retired number |
| 50% | ANGELS | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Rod Carew's number 29 |
| 50% | GALAXY | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Cobi Jones's number 13 |
| 50% | SPARKS | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Lisa Leslie's number 9 |
| 50% | CHARGERS | 8 | Los Angeles team that retired Junior Seau's number 55 |
| 50% | METS | 4 | New York team that retired Mike Piazza's number 31 |
| 50% | RANGERS | 7 | New York team that retired Mark Messier's number 11 |
| 50% | KNICKS | 6 | New York team that retired Patrick Ewing's number 33 |
| 50% | YANKEES | 7 | New York team that retired Derek Jeter's number 2 |