| 100% | CELERY | 6 | Many eat this stalk with peanut butter |
| 44% | OREO | 4 | Cookie eaten with peanut butter in "The Parent Trap" |
| 41% | JELLY | 5 | Fruity spread often paired with peanut butter |
| 38% | ANTSONALOG | 10 | Celery topped with peanut butter and raisins |
| 38% | ANTSONALOG | 10 | Celery sticks topped with peanut butter and raisins |
| 38% | FLUFFERNUTTERS | 14 | Sandwiches made with peanut butter and marshmallow creme |
| 37% | ANTS | 4 | ___ on a log (celery with peanut butter and raisins) |
| 37% | MOOSETRACKS | 11 | Vanilla ice cream with peanut butter cups and fudge |
| 35% | AMEN | 4 | Many prayers end with this |
| 35% | PINECONE | 8 | Item covered with peanut butter to make a bird feeder: 2 wds. |
| 35% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter brand with Extra Crunchy and Natural Creamy varieties |
| 35% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter with Extra Crunchy and Natural Honey Creamy varieties |
| 34% | SLUR | 4 | Talk around a mouthful of Texas toast smothered with peanut butter, for example |
| 34% | CANVAS | 6 | Most artists start with this blank medium |
| 33% | COMPUTERS | 9 | Many new book illustrations are made with these |
| 33% | PEANUT | 6 | This legume butter is a natural pair with jelly |
| 32% | SIXTEEN | 7 | Molly Ringwald celebrated with this many candles |
| 32% | RICHER | 6 | Made with more butter and cream, perhaps |
| 32% | CREAMIEST | 9 | Most smooth, as peanut butter |
| 31% | STRAWBERRYJAM | 13 | *Common peanut butter go-with |
| 31% | BITEOFF | 7 | Don't do this with more than you can chew |
| 30% | ONEWAYSTREETS | 13 | Most crosstown thoroughfares in Manhattan ... with a hint to this puzzle's theme |
| 29% | ANEWBIRTH | 9 | With 23-Across, what this puzzle's subject promised in his most famous address |
| 29% | FLAMINGO | 8 | The more shrimp this bird eats, the pinker it gets |
| 29% | PIG | 3 | *Animal that goes "oink" ... or eat, eat, and eat some more with "out" |
| 29% | XANDY | 5 | With 30-Across, what most numbers in the clues of this year's puzzles represent |
| 28% | CREAMY | 6 | Peanut butter choice |
| 28% | JIF | 3 | Peanut butter brand |
| 28% | JAR | 3 | Peanut butter container |
| 28% | SMOOTH | 6 | Peanut butter choice |