| 100% | SANITY | 6 | Marbles you don't play with |
| 58% | AWAYGAME | 8 | You don't play it at home |
| 58% | GAMES | 5 | Don't play ___ with me |
| 57% | PEEKABOO | 8 | "I don't see you!" game played with a baby |
| 52% | COOKIEJAR | 9 | You don't want to be caught with your hand in one |
| 52% | IMEANIT | 7 | "Don't play with me!" |
| 51% | BUSY | 4 | Sound you don't hear with voice mail |
| 51% | UNO | 3 | Game where you don't want a Skip card played on you |
| 50% | BITEOFF | 7 | Don't do this with more than you can chew |
| 50% | FROSTNIXON | 10 | 2006 play with question "Why didn't you burn the tapes?" |
| 49% | UNO | 3 | Game where you don't want a Wild Draw 4 card played on you |
| 48% | FAKEIT | 6 | Play a song you don't know, say |
| 48% | ATOY | 4 | "That is not ___!" ("Don't play with that!") |
| 48% | LETON | 5 | Say you don't know but do it with a "wink, wink, nudge, nudge", maybe |
| 48% | IKID | 4 | "Just playing with you!" |
| 47% | PAWAT | 5 | Play with, if you're a Persian |
| 47% | ATOY | 4 | "That's not ___!" ("Don't play with that!") (2 wds.) |
| 46% | NEWTOY | 6 | Something you love to play with |
| 46% | AGATE | 5 | Playing marble with bands |
| 46% | CROCE | 5 | "You Don't Mess Around With Jim" singer |
| 45% | CROCE | 5 | "You Don't Mess Around With Jim" singer, 1972 |
| 45% | MESS | 4 | "You Don't ___ with the Zohan" (Adam Sandler comedy) |
| 45% | MESS | 4 | "You Don't ___ Around With Jim" (Jim Croce song) |
| 45% | CROCE | 5 | "You Don't Mess Around With Jim" singer, aptly |
| 45% | WHOSWE | 6 | "Don't lump me in with you" |
| 45% | TONE | 4 | "Don't you take that __ with me!" |
| 45% | TONE | 4 | “Don’t you use that ___ with me!” |
| 44% | ATOY | 4 | "Put that down, it's not ___!" ("Don't play with that!"): 2 wds. |
| 44% | OHNO | 4 | "___ you don't!" |
| 44% | MESS | 4 | "You Don't ___ with the Zohan" (2008 Adam Sandler film) |