| 100% | BRODERICK | 9 | Matthew —, 1983 Best Featured Actor in a Play Tony Award winner for Brighton Beach Memoirs |
| 59% | TEALE | 5 | Owen —, Welsh actor; 1997 Best Featured Actor in a Play Tony Award winner for A Doll's House |
| 48% | NATHANLANE | 10 | 2001 Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award winner for The Producers |
| 47% | DELATOUR | 8 | Frances —, 2006 Tony Award Best Featured Actress in a Play winner for The History Boys |
| 46% | RIGG | 4 | Diana —, 1994 Best Actress in a Play Tony Award winner for Medea |
| 46% | GOULET | 6 | Robert —, 1968 Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award winner for The Happy Time |
| 42% | STRITCH | 7 | Elaine —, 1956 Tony Award Best Featured Actress in a Play nominee for Bus Stop |
| 42% | BERTISH | 7 | Suzanne —, 1995 Tony Award Best Featured Actress in a Play nominee for The Moliere Comedies |
| 39% | LAPOTAIRE | 9 | Jane —, 1981 Tony Award Best Actress in a Play winner for Piaf |
| 39% | HODGE | 5 | Douglas —, 2010 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical winner for La Cage aux Folles |
| 39% | DAVIDALANGRIER | 14 | "A Soldier's Play" actor who won the 2020 Tony Award for Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Play (3 wds.) |
| 38% | JOHNS | 5 | Glynis —, 1973 Best Actress in a Musical Tony Award winner for A Little Night Music |
| 38% | TUTIN | 5 | Dorothy —, 1968 Best Actress in a Play Tony Award nominee for Portrait of a Queen |
| 37% | DALY | 4 | Tyne —, 1990 Tony Award for Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical winner for Gypsy |
| 37% | EZIOPINZA | 9 | 1950 Tony winner for Best Actor in a Musical |
| 37% | SAMMENDES | 9 | "The Ferryman" director who won the Tony Award for Best Direction of a Play in 2019 (2 wds.) |
| 36% | FRANKLANGELLA | 13 | "The Americans" actor who won two Tony Awards for Best Actor in a Play, for "Frost/Nixon" and "The Father" (2 wds.) |
| 36% | BRYANCRANSTON | 13 | "Breaking Bad" actor who won two Tony Awards for Best Actor in a Play, for "All the Way" and "Network" (2 wds.) |
| 35% | AUTEUIL | 7 | Daniel —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role BAFTA Film Award winner for Jean de Florette |
| 35% | JEREMYSTRONG | 12 | "Succession" actor who won the 2024 Best Leading Actor in a Play Tony for "An Enemy of the People": 2 wds. |
| 35% | CHRISCOOPER | 11 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Adaptation |
| 35% | JOEPESCI | 8 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Goodfellas |
| 35% | REDBUTTONS | 10 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Sayonara |
| 35% | JIMBROADBENT | 12 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Iris |
| 35% | PETERUSTINOV | 12 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Topkapi |
| 35% | DONAMECHE | 9 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Cocoon |
| 35% | TIMCURRY | 8 | 2005 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical nominee for his role as King Arthur in Spamalot |
| 35% | WALLACEBEERY | 12 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar winner for The Champ |