| 100% | KEA | 3 | Mauna __: alphabetically first of two Hawaiian volcanoes with similar names |
| 59% | KEA | 3 | Alphabetically first of two Hawaiian maunas |
| 41% | HENRI | 5 | With 63-Across, first two names of Guy de Maupassant |
| 35% | PIUSI | 5 | First of 12 popes with a religious-sounding name |
| 35% | PELE | 4 | Hawaiian goddess of fire and volcanoes, who shares her name with a famed Brazilian soccer player |
| 34% | EMILYJANE | 9 | Two first names of Wuthering Heights author |
| 33% | GEORGE | 6 | First name of American President with ivory teeth |
| 33% | ELLA | 4 | First name of a singer with 13 Grammys |
| 33% | NICKI | 5 | First name of rapper with an Anaconda, __ Minaj |
| 33% | ELLEN | 5 | First name of two first ladies |
| 33% | ABIGAIL | 7 | First name of two first ladies |
| 33% | MEL | 3 | First name of two Spice Girls |
| 33% | AARON | 5 | Alphabetically first of the 100 most popular boys' names in the U.S. |
| 33% | AARON | 5 | First name alphabetically in the Baseball Hall of Fame |
| 33% | ANDREW | 6 | First name of two U.S. presidents |
| 33% | JIMMY | 5 | First name of two late-night hosts |
| 32% | RENEE | 5 | First name of the alphabetically last Best Actress Oscar winner |
| 32% | MEL | 3 | First name shared by two of the five Spice Girls |
| 32% | SETH | 4 | First name of the athlete with the Instagram handle @sdotcurry |
| 32% | JIMMY | 5 | First name of two network late-night hosts |
| 32% | CRUE | 4 | One of two words with an umlaut in a metal band's name |
| 32% | CLIVE | 5 | First name of a music mogul that rhymes with a number |
| 32% | BBKING | 6 | Blues royalty with two initials as his first name |
| 32% | TAN | 3 | One of two Crayola colors with the shortest name |
| 31% | RHETT | 5 | First name of Clark Gable's character in "Gone With the Wind" |
| 31% | ANNE | 4 | First name of two of Henry VIII's six wives |
| 31% | STEVE | 5 | First name of two of the three Apple co-founders |
| 31% | ANNE | 4 | First name of two of King Henry VIII's wives |
| 31% | THIS | 4 | First of two choices |
| 31% | BEFORE | 6 | First of two pictures |