| 100% | MENORCA | 7 | Mediterranean resort island, to locals |
| 76% | MALLORCA | 8 | Spanish resort island, to locals |
| 76% | MENORCA | 7 | Spanish resort island, to locals |
| 61% | MINORCA | 7 | Mediterranean resort island |
| 61% | IBIZA | 5 | Mediterranean resort island |
| 54% | MENORCA | 7 | Spanish island, to locals |
| 52% | KRITI | 5 | Largest Greek island, to locals |
| 50% | SICILIA | 7 | Palermo’s island, to the locals |
| 49% | NUI | 3 | Rapa ___ (Easter Island, to locals) |
| 46% | SICILIA | 7 | 20-Across's island, to locals |
| 45% | SARDINE | 7 | Fish said to be named for a Mediterranean island |
| 41% | ARUBA | 5 | Resort island |
| 41% | RIVIERA | 7 | Mediterranean resort area |
| 41% | MINORCA | 7 | Mediterranean resort site |
| 40% | ARUBA | 5 | Resort island off Venezuela |
| 40% | ISCHIA | 6 | Resort island off Naples |
| 40% | ARUBA | 5 | Resort island near Curacao |
| 40% | ARUBA | 5 | Resort island near Venezuela |
| 40% | LIDO | 4 | Resort island near Venice |
| 40% | IBIZA | 5 | Resort island near Majorca |
| 40% | CAPRI | 5 | Resort island in Italy |
| 40% | BALI | 4 | Resort island of Indonesia |
| 40% | BALI | 4 | Resort island near Java |
| 40% | BALI | 4 | Resort island in Indonesia |
| 40% | CAPRI | 5 | Resort island near Naples |
| 40% | IBIZA | 5 | Resort island of Spain |
| 40% | ARUBA | 5 | Resort island near Curaçao |
| 40% | LAHABANA | 8 | Caribbean capital, to locals |
| 40% | INDY | 4 | Midwest capital, to locals |
| 40% | ODESA | 5 | Ukrainian port, to locals |