| 100% | BOSSY | 5 | Mike of the Stanley Cup-winning New York Islanders |
| 57% | KEENAN | 6 | Coach Mike of the 1994 Stanley Cup-winning Rangers |
| 55% | ISLANDERS | 9 | New York team with four Stanley Cup wins in the 1980s |
| 49% | BOBBYORR | 8 | Scorer of the "flying goal" to win the 1970 Stanley Cup |
| 49% | ORR | 3 | Scorer of the "flying goal" that won the 1970 Stanley Cup |
| 47% | BRIANDABOLL | 11 | New York Giants coach who won the 2022 NFL Coach of the Year award: 2 wds. |
| 46% | BRIANDABOLL | 11 | New York Giants coach who won the 2022 Associated Press NFL Coach of the Year Award (2 wds.) |
| 46% | KNICKS | 6 | New York ___, NBA team that has won 193 games in the playoffs over the course of their history |
| 45% | BUFFALOSABRES | 13 | NHL team based in New York that has never won the Stanley Cup: 2 wds. |
| 44% | LONG | 4 | ___ Island (home of the New York Islanders NHL team) |
| 44% | YANKEES | 7 | The New York ___, MLB team that has won the most number of World Series championships with 27 wins |
| 43% | METS | 4 | New York rivals of the Yankees |
| 43% | HARLEM | 6 | New York home of the Globetrotters |
| 42% | ISLANDERS | 9 | Team with four Stanley Cup wins in the 1980s |
| 42% | BLACKHAWKS | 10 | Team with three Stanley Cup wins in the 2010s |
| 42% | CANADIENS | 9 | Team with six Stanley Cup wins in the 1970s |
| 42% | BRONXZOO | 8 | New York home of the Himalayan Highlands |
| 42% | RYE | 3 | New York home of the Dragon Coaster |
| 42% | PELE | 4 | New York Cosmos star of the '70s |
| 42% | CANADIENS | 9 | Montreal team with six Stanley Cup wins in the 1970s |
| 42% | BLACKHAWKS | 10 | Chicago team with three Stanley Cup wins in the 2010s |
| 42% | TISCH | 5 | New York University's ___ School of the Arts |
| 42% | NYACK | 5 | New York home of the painter Edward Hopper |
| 42% | PLAZAHOTEL | 10 | New York City setting of the "Eloise" books |
| 42% | CITI | 4 | New York's ___ Field (home of the Mets) |
| 42% | ELI | 3 | Manning of the New York Giants |
| 42% | GREELEY | 7 | Founder of the New York Tribune |
| 42% | OCHS | 4 | Adolph of The New York Times |
| 42% | OTT | 3 | Mel ___ of the New York Giants |
| 42% | ALEX | 4 | Rodriguez of the New York Yankees |