| 100% | NABI | 4 | Mohammad —, former Afghanistan cricket captain |
| 54% | IMRANKHAN | 9 | Former Pakistani cricket captain, and PM in 2018 |
| 42% | SHAH | 4 | Former Afghanistan ruler |
| 36% | LARSSON | 7 | Striker Henrik __, former Sweden captain |
| 36% | JACKDAW | 7 | Captain Britain's former sidekick |
| 35% | JAMESMAY | 8 | Former Top Gear presenter, Captain Slow |
| 35% | ASHE | 4 | Former Davis Cup captain |
| 34% | CHAPPELL | 8 | G S —, Australia Test cricket captain from 1975-83 |
| 34% | ASHE | 4 | Former Davis Cup captain Arthur |
| 33% | REYNA | 5 | Former U.S. men's soccer captain Claudio |
| 32% | SHEPPARD | 8 | David —, Bishop of Liverpool from 1975-97; 1954 England Test cricket captain |
| 31% | AROD | 4 | Former Yankee who was teammates with Sandman and Captain Clutch |
| 31% | DEXTER | 6 | E R —, former England Test cricket captain born in Milan, Italy, in 1935 |
| 29% | JESSEVENTURA | 12 | Former wrestler who played Captain Freedom in "The Running Man": 2 wds. |
| 29% | RIVES | 5 | Jean-Pierre —, former France rugby union captain nicknamed Golden Helmet |
| 29% | GREG | 4 | ___ Chappell, Australian former cricketer who was also the team captain |
| 29% | PANAMA | 6 | Where Harlem Globetrotter former captain "Special K" Daley was born |
| 29% | RIVES | 5 | Jean-Pierre -, former France rugby union captain nicknamed Golden Helmet |
| 29% | STRAUSS | 7 | A J —, England Test cricket captain who hit 110 against Australia in Brisbane in 2010 |
| 28% | VINCE | 5 | J M —, 2016 England Test cricket debutant; Hampshire captain from 2015 |
| 28% | IMRAN | 5 | & 5D Captain of the Pakistan 1992 Cricket World Cup-winning team |
| 28% | ROBSHAW | 7 | Chris —, former Harlequins and England rugby union captain born in 1986 |
| 27% | TERRY | 5 | John -, former England and Chelsea captain; spent 19 years at the club |
| 26% | CORRY | 5 | Martin —, former England rugby union captain whose 1997 Test debut was against Argentina |
| 26% | HADLEE | 6 | Richard ___, former cricketer from New Zealand who was knighted for his contributions to cricket |
| 25% | SACHIN | 6 | ___ Tendulkar, former cricketer from India who also served as the captain of the national team |
| 25% | DAWES | 5 | John —, former Wales, British and Irish Lions and Barbarians rugby union captain born in 1940 |
| 24% | LEES | 4 | A Z —, Durham and former Yorkshire batsman; 2014 Cricket Writers' Club Young Cricketer of the Year |
| 24% | VIVIAN | 6 | Sir ___ Richards, former cricketer who represented West Indies and was knighted for his contributions to cricket |