| 100% | SCAMS | 5 | Most deals that sound too good to be true |
| 72% | SCAM | 4 | Deal that's too good to be true, often |
| 67% | SCAM | 4 | What a deal that's too good to be true probably is |
| 67% | SCAM | 4 | Offer that's too good to be true, many times |
| 61% | SCAM | 4 | In retrospect, it may have sounded too good to be true |
| 59% | SCAM | 4 | Offer that seems too good to be true, probably |
| 59% | SCAM | 4 | Offer that's too good to be true, often |
| 59% | TRUE | 4 | "That sounds too good to be ___!" |
| 57% | SCAM | 4 | Telemarketing call that seems too good to be true, probably |
| 57% | SPAM | 4 | Messages that are often too good to be true |
| 56% | SCAM | 4 | Almost any offer that's too good to be true |
| 52% | WAS | 3 | "I knew it ___ too good to be true" |
| 52% | WHATSTHECATCH | 13 | "Isn't this too good to be true . . .?" |
| 52% | HASACATCH | 9 | Is too good to be true |
| 48% | TRUE | 4 | "Sounds too good to be ___" |
| 47% | SCAMS | 5 | "Too good to be true" offers, often |
| 44% | TRUE | 4 | Too good to be ___ |
| 43% | TOO | 3 | ___ good to be true |
| 43% | TOO | 3 | "___ good to be true!" |
| 43% | TOO | 3 | "___ good to be true." |
| 43% | TOO | 3 | "___ good to be true" |
| 43% | HOWAREYOUREAL | 13 | Rhetorical question to one who's too good to be true |
| 42% | ISTOO | 5 | "This ___ good to be true!" |
| 42% | ISTOO | 5 | “This ___ good to be true!” |
| 42% | ALTER | 5 | Change to fit better, as pants that are too long |
| 42% | TOO | 3 | "It's ___ good to be true!" |
| 42% | TOO | 3 | "It's ___ good to be true" |
| 42% | TRUE | 4 | "It's too good to be ___!" |
| 42% | FEELS | 5 | "It ___ too good to be back!" |
| 41% | IMUST | 5 | "___ be dreaming!" ("This is too good to be true!") (2 wds.) |