| 100% | FAUNS | 5 | Mr. Tumnus in the "Narnia" books and others |
| 60% | FAUN | 4 | Mr. Tumnus, in “The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe,” for one |
| 57% | FAUN | 4 | Mr. Tumnus, in "The Chronicles of Narnia" |
| 52% | SUSAN | 5 | Sister of Peter, Edmund and Lucy, in the Narnia books |
| 51% | ETALII | 6 | And others, in the Forum |
| 49% | JACOB | 5 | Werewolf in the "Twilight" books and films |
| 48% | FEARS | 5 | Being in the dark, maybe, and others |
| 48% | THEWOODS | 8 | In the musical, Little Red and others go into it |
| 47% | ARTWORK | 7 | Illustrations and other drawn material in a book |
| 47% | EAR | 3 | In one and out the other? |
| 47% | EAR | 3 | In one ___ and out the other |
| 47% | ONE | 3 | In ___ ear and out the other |
| 46% | JUDYBLUME | 9 | Novelist who wrote "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret" and the other three frequently banned books in this puzzle (2 wds.) |
| 46% | SPOT | 4 | Dog in the "Dick and Jane" children's book series |
| 46% | ONE | 3 | In __ ear and out the other |
| 46% | EAR | 3 | In one __ and out the other |
| 45% | GATEFOLD | 8 | Book page, wider than the others and bent back |
| 45% | ONEEAR | 6 | In ___ and out the other (2 wds.) |
| 45% | ASTA | 4 | Dog who's female in the book and male in the film |
| 44% | ODIE | 4 | Dog in the 2008 book "30 Years of Laughs and Lasagna" |
| 44% | FAD | 3 | It goes in one era and out the other |
| 44% | FAD | 3 | It's in one year and out the other |
| 44% | FAD | 3 | It's in one era and out the other |
| 44% | FADS | 4 | They're in one year and out the other |
| 44% | THERANOS | 8 | Company in the book Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies in a Silicon Valley Startup |
| 43% | HYDE | 4 | Mr. ___ (Dr. Jekyll's other identity, in a Robert Louis Stevenson book) |
| 43% | POLESAPART | 10 | In complete opposition ... and a feature of the four other longest answers |
| 43% | HEISTS | 6 | The job in "The Italian Job," and others |
| 43% | DONS | 4 | Barzini and others, in "The Godfather" |
| 42% | CHRISNOTH | 9 | He played Mr. Big in Sex and the City |