| 100% | ODIN | 4 | Mr. Wednesday's true identity in Neil Gaiman's "American Gods" |
| 62% | ODIN | 4 | Mr. Wednesday's real identity in "American Gods" |
| 61% | ODIN | 4 | Mr. Wednesday's real identity, in "American Gods" |
| 36% | PORTIA | 6 | Balthasar's true identity, in Shakespeare |
| 34% | ODIN | 4 | Shadow's father in American Gods |
| 34% | GODS | 4 | Neil Gaiman's "American __" |
| 34% | GODS | 4 | Neil Gaiman's "American ___" |
| 33% | GODS | 4 | Neil Gaiman novel, American __ |
| 32% | HYDE | 4 | Mr. ___ (Dr. Jekyll's other identity, in a Robert Louis Stevenson book) |
| 32% | GODS | 4 | "American ___," Neil Gaiman's novel |
| 31% | MORPHEUS | 8 | Lord of Dreams in Neil Gaiman comic |
| 29% | IANMCSHANE | 10 | The actor who plays Mr. Wednesday on the TV series "American Gods": 2 wds. |
| 29% | SCIENCE | 7 | "It's true whether or not you believe in it," per Neil deGrasse Tyson |
| 28% | GAIMAN | 6 | Writer Neil, known for The Sandman, American Gods |
| 27% | ELISE | 5 | Lady in a Beethoven title whose true identity remains unknown |
| 27% | ELIOT | 5 | Mr. Rosewater in Kurt Vonnegut's "God Bless You, Mr. Rosewater" |
| 26% | INCOGNITO | 9 | Someone's true identity concealed |
| 26% | UNMASKING | 9 | Revealing someone’s true identity |
| 26% | CHU | 3 | Little panda with a big sneeze in a Neil Gaiman kidlit series |
| 26% | SANDMAN | 7 | Neil Gaiman's comic series published by DC |
| 26% | EUGENE | 6 | Wednesday's bee buddy in the TV series |
| 26% | CORA | 4 | Mr. Dithers's wife in "Blondie" |
| 25% | EDWARD | 6 | __ Teach; Blackbeard the pirate's true identity |
| 25% | CESARIO | 7 | Viola's false identity in "Twelfth Night" |
| 25% | BEADLE | 6 | Mr. Bumble's position in "Oliver Twist" |
| 25% | NEIL | 4 | "American Gods" novelist Gaiman |
| 25% | NEIL | 4 | "American Gods" author Gaiman |
| 25% | IFSO | 4 | In case it's true |
| 25% | IFSO | 4 | In case that's true |
| 25% | YONKERS | 7 | Neil Simon's "Lost in ___" |