| 100% | STATLER | 7 | Muppet who frequently appears with Waldorf |
| 44% | ERNIE | 5 | Muppet who rooms with Bert |
| 44% | BERT | 4 | Muppet who lives with Ernie |
| 42% | ERNIE | 5 | Muppet who wears a shirt with horizontal stripes |
| 41% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet who appeared on the 2016 Daytime Emmy Awards |
| 41% | MISSPIGGY | 9 | Muppet who is in love with Kermit the Frog |
| 41% | GONZO | 5 | Muppet who's in love with Camilla the Chicken |
| 40% | ELMO | 4 | Ticklish red Muppet who frequently refers to himself in the third person |
| 40% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet who feuded with Zoey over her pet rock Rocco |
| 40% | ERNIE | 5 | Muppet who sings many duets with Bert on "Sesame Street" |
| 40% | ELMO | 4 | Red Muppet who appeared on "The West Wing" |
| 40% | SONDRA | 6 | Locke who frequently co-starred with Clint Eastwood |
| 39% | SIA | 3 | Singer who frequently covers her face with her hair |
| 39% | WALTER | 6 | Actor Matthau who frequently co-starred with Jack Lemmon |
| 39% | GIL | 3 | Evans who frequently collaborated with Miles Davis |
| 39% | DAY | 3 | Doris who frequently costarred with Rock Hudson |
| 39% | BILLDANA | 8 | Comedian who frequently appeared on The Ed Sullivan Show as the astronaut José Jiménez |
| 39% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet who discussed acting technique with Robert De Niro on “Sesame Street” |
| 37% | EDBURNS | 7 | Writer/producer who frequently collaborates with David Simon |
| 37% | SIWA | 4 | JoJo who appeared on Dancing With the Stars |
| 37% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet who did a skit about respect with Tyrion and Cersei from "Game of Thrones" |
| 36% | OHARA | 5 | Catherine who has frequently co-starred with Eugene Levy |
| 36% | PETERLORRE | 10 | Actor who appeared in nine films with Sydney Greenstreet |
| 36% | KERMITTHEFROG | 13 | "Sesame Street" Muppet who begins his roving reporter segments with "Hi-ho!" (3 wds.) |
| 35% | ALTHEA | 6 | With 32-Across, tennis legend who appeared on "Forever" stamps in 2013 |
| 35% | ERNIE | 5 | Golfer Els who shares his first name with a Muppet |
| 35% | ODOM | 4 | Athlete Lamar who appeared on "Keeping Up With the Kardashians" |
| 35% | AZARIA | 6 | Hank who refused to appear in “The Problem with Apu” |
| 35% | TOMDELAY | 8 | Ex-Texas Congressman who appeared on Dancing with the Stars |
| 35% | GABLE | 5 | Actor Clark who appeared in eight films with Joan Crawford |