| 100% | CATS | 4 | Musical with the characters Skimbleshanks and Mr. Mistoffelees |
| 55% | CATS | 4 | Musical with the feline characters Grizabella and Macavity |
| 52% | CATS | 4 | Musical with the song "Mr. Mistoffelees" |
| 51% | BOJACKHORSEMAN | 14 | Show with the characters Mr. Peanutbutter, a dog, and Sextina Aquafina, a dolphin |
| 48% | CATS | 4 | Skimbleshanks and Mr. Mistoffelees, for two |
| 44% | RENT | 4 | Musical with the songs "Santa Fe" and "I Should Tell You" |
| 43% | {BOY/GIRL}MEETSWORLD | 20 | Sitcom with the characters Cory and Topanga |
| 43% | CABARET | 7 | Musical with Sally Bowles and the Emcee |
| 43% | NEWSIES | 7 | Musical with the songs "Carrying the Banner" and "The World Will Know" |
| 43% | ROOTS | 5 | Classic miniseries with the characters Kunta Kinte and Chicken George |
| 42% | GUNSMOKE | 8 | Old TV western with the characters Matt Dillon and Miss Kitty |
| 42% | INSIDEOUT | 9 | Pixar film with the characters Joy, Sadness, Fear, Anger, and Disgust |
| 42% | EVITA | 5 | Musical with the songs "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" and "A New Argentina" |
| 41% | PEARLSBEFORESWINE | 17 | Comic strip with the characters Rat and Pig |
| 40% | AAU | 3 | Org. with the Sullivan Award for character, leadership and sportsmanship |
| 40% | XXXX | 4 | Musical with "Mr. Mistoffelees" |
| 39% | RENT | 4 | 1990s musical featuring the characters Roger, Mimi, and Tom Collins |
| 38% | SKYMASTERSON | 12 | Character in the musical Guys and Dolls who marries Sarah Brown |
| 38% | BYEBYEBIRDIE | 12 | Musical with the song "Put On a Happy Face," and a hint to making four answers match their starred clues |
| 38% | EDGES | 5 | Pasek and Paul musical with the song "Lying There" |
| 38% | FRANKENWEENIE | 13 | 2012 stop motion film directed by Tim Burton with the characters voiced by Martin Short and Winona Ryder |
| 38% | ALECTO | 6 | Character in Greek mythology who, with Megaera and Tisiphone, comprised the Erinyes |
| 38% | GREMLINS | 8 | 1984 comedy horror movie with the characters Gizmo and Stripe |
| 37% | ALECTO | 6 | Character in Greek mythology who, with Megaera and Tisiphone, comprised the three Erinyes |
| 37% | HUMBERT | 7 | Literary character with the same first and last name |
| 37% | CATS | 4 | Musical with the song "Memory" |
| 37% | ANNIE | 5 | Musical with the song "Tomorrow" |
| 37% | CHESS | 5 | Musical with the song "Endgame" |
| 37% | HAIR | 4 | Musical with the song "Aquarius" |
| 37% | WILLY | 5 | With 34-Across, colorful character in Roald Dahl's "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" |