| 100% | VAMPIRES | 8 | Mythical creatures who look human, have fangs and live off human blood |
| 43% | SELKIES | 7 | Mythical Scottish creatures who are human and seal |
| 35% | SPHINX | 6 | Mythical creature with a human head and lion body |
| 34% | MERMAID | 7 | Mythical creature with a human body and a fish's tail |
| 33% | CENTAUR | 7 | Mythical creature and dog have neat arrangement |
| 33% | CENTAUR | 7 | Mythical creature and mongrel have neat arrangement |
| 33% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Creature that sucks blood and lives eternally |
| 33% | WEREWOLF | 8 | Mythical creature who is human, except on full moon nights - when it transforms into a large canine |
| 32% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Undead creature who feeds from live people's blood |
| 29% | CAESAR | 6 | Who says, in Shakespeare, “Yond Cassius has a lean and hungry look” |
| 29% | EVANS | 5 | Chris ___, actor who has played both Captain America and Human Torch |
| 29% | NIN | 3 | Novelist who wrote "I have no fear of depths and a great fear of shallow living" |
| 28% | AWOL | 4 | Soldier who's off the base and doesn't have a pass: Abbr. |
| 28% | NICKIMINAJ | 10 | "Anaconda" singer who has lived in both Trinidad and the US: 2 wds. |
| 28% | BROWNIE | 7 | Mythical creature who cleans house, drinks milk |
| 27% | ANNA | 4 | ___ Paquin and Stephen Moyer, couple who took their romance on "True Blood" off-screen |
| 27% | SEANKINGSTON | 12 | "Beautiful Girls" singer who has lived in both Jamaica and the US: 2 wds. |
| 27% | PEGASUS | 7 | Mythical creature which looks like a winged stallion |
| 27% | MADEA | 5 | Tyler Perry character who has appeared in 11 live-action films and one animated film |
| 27% | WYCLEFJEAN | 10 | "Gone Till November" rapper who has lived in both Haiti and the US: 2 wds. |
| 27% | ENOS | 4 | Biblical character who had a son at age 90 and then lived another 815 years |
| 27% | SASHEERZAMATA | 13 | Female performer currently on "Saturday Night Live" who has impersonated Michelle Obama and Rihanna: 2 wds. |
| 26% | SKYDIVERS | 9 | People who jump out of planes and live |
| 26% | CAREGIVER | 9 | Person who looks after residents in assisted living |
| 26% | PAUL | 4 | ___ Simon, American musician and actor who has hosted "Saturday Night Live" 4 times as of June 2020 |
| 26% | TINA | 4 | ___ Fey, American actress and comedian who has hosted "Saturday Night Live" 6 times as of June 2020 |
| 26% | HILL | 4 | Jonah ___, American actor and comedian who has hosted "Saturday Night Live" 5 times as of June 2020 |
| 26% | BALDWIN | 7 | Alec ___, American actor and comedian who has hosted "Saturday Night Live" 17 times as of June 2020 |
| 26% | WILL | 4 | ___ Ferrell, American actor and comedian who has hosted "Saturday Night Live" 5 times as of June 2020 |
| 26% | ANIMAL | 6 | Creature has article to mail off |