| 100% | CRETAN | 6 | Native of the Greek island where the Minotaur lived |
| 54% | CRETE | 5 | Grecian island where the mythical Minotaur lived |
| 53% | MELOS | 5 | English name of the Greek island in the SW Aegean Sea where the Venus de Milo was found |
| 50% | AEGEAN | 6 | Sea where the Greek island of Santorini is located |
| 49% | ALEUT | 5 | Native of the Shumagin Islands |
| 48% | CRETE | 5 | Island where the Minotaur was trapped |
| 47% | NEVERLAND | 9 | The imaginary island where Peter Pan lives |
| 47% | CRETE | 5 | Largest of the Greek islands |
| 46% | CRETE | 5 | Greek-island setting for the myth of the Minotaur |
| 45% | IDA | 3 | Highest mountain in Crete, largest of the Greek islands |
| 45% | MYKONOS | 7 | Greek island where Zeus battled the Titans |
| 45% | ORCADIAN | 8 | Native or inhabitant of the Orkney Islands |
| 45% | SAMOS | 5 | Greek island off the coast of Turkey |
| 44% | LABYRINTH | 9 | Ancient Greek maze, where the Minotaur was hidden |
| 44% | GALAPAGOS | 9 | Islands where the world's biggest tortoises live |
| 44% | MAJORCA | 7 | Island where the resort of Magaluf is located |
| 44% | CRETE | 5 | Island of the Minotaur |
| 44% | SCOT | 4 | Native of the country where whiskey originated, for short |
| 44% | ANDROS | 6 | Northernmost of the Greek Cyclades island group |
| 44% | CRETE | 5 | Island home of the Minotaur |
| 43% | MAURITIUS | 9 | Indian Ocean island where the dodo once lived |
| 43% | SKYROS | 6 | Greek island; largest of the Sporades |
| 43% | ATI | 3 | Native people of the Philippine islands of Boracay, Panay and Negros |
| 43% | BALI | 4 | Island where the "Love" part of "Eat Pray Love" took place |
| 43% | CORFU | 5 | The Durrells lived on this Greek island |
| 42% | LESBOS | 6 | Greek island off the NW coast of Turkey whose capital is Mytilene |
| 42% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island where the Triple Crown of Surfing is held |
| 42% | OAHU | 4 | Island where about two thirds of Hawaiians live |
| 42% | OLYMPUS | 7 | Mountain where the Greek gods lived |
| 41% | CUBA | 4 | Island where Hemingway lived in the 1940s and '50s |