| 100% | IMPISHLY | 8 | Naughtily, like a mythical creature |
| 69% | PEGASUS | 7 | Mythical creature which looks like a winged stallion |
| 65% | NOME | 4 | Alaskan city whose name sounds like a small mythical creature |
| 60% | NEMEAN | 6 | Like a mythical lion |
| 60% | TROJAN | 6 | Like a mythical wooden horse |
| 60% | FOXY | 4 | Like a sly forest creature |
| 57% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical horse-like creature with a single horn |
| 57% | ORC | 3 | Mythical creature like ogre |
| 56% | YETI | 4 | Cooler brand named for a mythical creature |
| 56% | MER | 3 | Prefix with "maid" for a mythical creature |
| 56% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical creature with a horn |
| 56% | GENIE | 5 | Mythical creature in a lamp |
| 55% | EELY | 4 | Slippery like a certain creature |
| 55% | YETI | 4 | Cooler manufacturer whose eponym is a mythical creature |
| 55% | YETI | 4 | Water bottle brand named for a mythical creature |
| 54% | IMMORTAL | 8 | Quality of a mythical creature who can never die |
| 54% | GNOME | 5 | Mythical creature often spotted in a garden |
| 54% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical creature also known as a monoceros |
| 54% | GOBLIN | 6 | A mythical humanoid creature that causes mischief |
| 54% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical creature, or a billion-dollar startup |
| 53% | WEREWOLF | 8 | Mythical creature that awakens in a Moon phase |
| 52% | YETI | 4 | Cooler brand whose name is also that of a mythical creature |
| 52% | SPHINX | 6 | Mythical creature with a human head and lion body |
| 52% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical creature that's a national symbol of Scotland |
| 52% | CENTICORE | 9 | European mythical creature also called a yale |
| 51% | SPHINX | 6 | Mythical creature: head of a human, body of a lion |
| 51% | GNOME | 5 | Mythical creature whose statues can be spotted in a garden |
| 51% | MER | 3 | Prefix with "maid" for a mythical sea creature |
| 50% | MERMAID | 7 | Mythical creature with a human body and a fish's tail |
| 50% | CRABBIEST | 9 | Most grumpy, or most like a shelled beach creature |