| 100% | OTSEGO | 6 | New York lake that's the source of the Susquehanna River |
| 68% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that's the source of the Niagara River |
| 68% | XXXX | 4 | Lake that's the source of the Niagara River |
| 67% | ITASCA | 6 | Minnesota lake that's the source of the Mississippi River |
| 58% | ITASCA | 6 | Lake that's the source of the Mississippi |
| 57% | PERU | 4 | Country that's the source of the Amazon River |
| 56% | ITASCA | 6 | Minnesota lake that's the headwater of the Mississippi River |
| 56% | ITASCA | 6 | Lake that's a source of the Mississippi |
| 53% | SINGSING | 8 | *Prison on the Hudson that's the source of "up the river" |
| 51% | ITASCA | 6 | Lake that is a source of the Mississippi |
| 50% | ERIE | 4 | Lake source of the Niagara River |
| 50% | ERIE | 4 | Lake ___, source of the Niagara River |
| 49% | ITASCA | 6 | Minnesota lake at the source of the Mississippi River |
| 49% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that's one of the sources of Niagara Falls |
| 49% | CHAUTAUQUA | 10 | New York lake that flows into the Allegheny |
| 47% | SARANAC | 7 | New York river that feeds Lake Champlain |
| 47% | FALLS | 5 | The Niagara ___, located in New York, that is one of America's natural wonders |
| 47% | OSAGE | 5 | 276-mile-long Missouri river that the Harry S. Truman Reservoir and the Lake of the Ozarks sits on |
| 46% | ERIE | 4 | New York canal that begins at the Hudson River |
| 46% | ITASCA | 6 | Lake —, source in Minnesota, US, of the Mississippi River |
| 46% | IOTA | 4 | Greek letter that's the source of the word "jot" |
| 45% | ERIE | 4 | Canal that spans the state of New York |
| 45% | ERIE | 4 | ___ Canal (waterway that connects a Great Lake to New York's Hudson River) |
| 45% | LUKE | 4 | Book that's the source of the phrase "Physician, heal thyself" |
| 45% | ELMIRA | 6 | Upstate New York city south of the Finger Lakes |
| 45% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that's largely fed by the Detroit River |
| 45% | GIRLS | 5 | Lena Dunham's hit comedy-drama that follows the lives of four young women in New York City |
| 45% | CACAO | 5 | Tree that's the source of chocolate |
| 45% | NUTMEG | 6 | Tree that's the source of mace |