| 100% | METS | 4 | New York team that retired Keith Hernandez's number 17 in 2022 |
| 52% | METS | 4 | New York team that retired Mike Piazza's number 31 |
| 52% | RANGERS | 7 | New York team that retired Mark Messier's number 11 |
| 52% | KNICKS | 6 | New York team that retired Patrick Ewing's number 33 |
| 52% | YANKEES | 7 | New York team that retired Derek Jeter's number 2 |
| 52% | GIANTS | 6 | New York team that retired Phil Simms's number 11 |
| 52% | JETS | 4 | New York team that retired Joe Namath's number 12 |
| 42% | LIBERTY | 7 | New York team that honored Teresa Weatherspoon's number 11 |
| 39% | THEJETS | 7 | New York team that plays its home games in New Jersey |
| 39% | METS | 4 | New York team that won the World Series in 1969 and 1986 |
| 38% | METS | 4 | Baseball team that plays home games in New York's Citi Field |
| 35% | TITANS | 6 | New York ___, NFL team that was rebranded as the New York Jets in 1963 |
| 34% | BUFFALOBILLS | 12 | Only N.F.L. team that plays its home games in New York |
| 33% | LAKERS | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Kareem Abdul-Jabbar's number 33 |
| 33% | DODGERS | 7 | Los Angeles team that retired Pee Wee Reese's number 1 |
| 33% | KNICKS | 6 | New York ___, NBA team that has won 193 games in the playoffs over the course of their history |
| 33% | GIANTS | 6 | San Francisco ___, Major League Baseball team that was founded in New York and relocated in 1958 |
| 33% | NETS | 4 | NBA team that retired Jason Kidd's #5 in 2013 |
| 33% | SPARKS | 6 | WNBA team that retired Lisa Leslie's number 9 |
| 33% | HEAT | 4 | Miami team that retired Dwyane Wade's number 3 |
| 33% | METS | 4 | New York team that plays home games at Citi Field |
| 32% | METS | 4 | New York MLB team featured in Ira Berkow's "Summers at Shea" |
| 31% | ANGELS | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Rod Carew's number 29 |
| 31% | GALAXY | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Cobi Jones's number 13 |
| 31% | SPARKS | 6 | Los Angeles team that retired Lisa Leslie's number 9 |
| 31% | CHARGERS | 8 | Los Angeles team that retired Junior Seau's number 55 |
| 31% | METS | 4 | New York team with a skyline in its logo |
| 31% | METS | 4 | Team that retired the numbers of Gil Hodges and Mike Piazza |
| 31% | METS | 4 | New York team whose last World Series appearance was in 2000 |
| 31% | ISLANDERS | 9 | New York team with four Stanley Cup wins in the 1980s |