| 100% | THURMANMUNSON | 13 | New York Yankees catching great who was the MLB's AL Rookie of the Year in 1970 (2 wds.) |
| 74% | CARLTONFISK | 11 | Boston Red Sox catching great who was the MLB's AL Rookie of the Year in 1972 (2 wds.) |
| 69% | JOHNNYBENCH | 11 | Cincinnati Reds catching great who was the MLB's NL Rookie of the Year in 1968 (2 wds.) |
| 53% | AARONJUDGE | 10 | New York Yankees outfielder who was the Associated Press Athlete of the Year in 2022: 2 wds. |
| 47% | SAUCEGARDNER | 12 | New York Jets cornerback who was the 2022 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: 2 wds. |
| 47% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | Yankees relief pitcher who won the MLB Comeback Player of the Year Award in 2013: 2 wds. |
| 45% | ROBINSONCANO | 12 | New York Yankees second baseman who was named MVP of the 2013 World Baseball Classic: 2 wds. |
| 45% | OCTAVIASPENCER | 14 | "The Help" Oscar winner who was Harvard's Hasty Pudding Woman of the Year in 2017: 2 wds. |
| 45% | AARON | 5 | With 30-Across, New York Yankees slugger who was Time's Athlete of the Year in 2022 |
| 45% | CHARLIZETHERON | 14 | "Monster" Oscar winner who was Harvard's Hasty Pudding Woman of the Year in 2008: 2 wds. |
| 45% | GUYLAFLEUR | 10 | A former New York Rangers player who was nicknamed "The Flower" who is considered one of the greatest hockey players in history: 2 wds. |
| 45% | RENEEZELLWEGER | 14 | "Cold Mountain" Oscar winner who was Harvard's Hasty Pudding Woman of the Year in 2009: 2 wds. |
| 44% | LAURYNHILL | 10 | "Everything Is Everything" singer who received the Grammys for both Album of the Year and Best New Artist in 1999: 2 wds. |
| 43% | DUSTINPEDROIA | 13 | Red Sox second baseman who was the 2007 AL Rookie of the Year & 2008 AL MVP: 2 wds. |
| 43% | MICAHPARSONS | 12 | Dallas Cowboys linebacker who was the 2021 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: 2 wds. |
| 42% | CHASEELLIOTT | 12 | 2020 NASCAR Cup Series champion who was also the NASCAR Rookie of the Year in 2016: 2 wds. |
| 42% | KYLELARSON | 10 | 2021 NASCAR Cup Series champion who was also the NASCAR Rookie of the Year in 2014: 2 wds. |
| 42% | CHINEYOGWUMIKE | 14 | Nigerian American WNBA player who was named Rookie of the Year in 2014: 2 wds. |
| 42% | JOEYLOGANO | 10 | 2018 and 2022 NASCAR Cup Series champion who was also the NASCAR Rookie of the Year in 2009: 2 wds. |
| 41% | ANDREWWIGGINS | 13 | 2015 NBA Rookie of the Year who was the first overall pick in the 2014 NBA draft (2 wds.) |
| 41% | CANDACEPARKER | 13 | Chicago Sky star who was named both WNBA Rookie of the Year and WNBA MVP in 2008: 2 wds. |
| 41% | AARON | 5 | Yankees slugger Judge who was the 2017 AL Rookie of the Year |
| 41% | ZACKBRITTON | 11 | New York Yankees pitcher who gave up the walk-off home run in the 30-Across game ( 2 wds.) |
| 40% | DEVINWILLIAMS | 13 | Brewers pitcher who the won National League Rookie of the Year Award in 2020: 2 wds. |
| 40% | BARACKOBAMA | 11 | Political victor who was Time's Person of the Year in 2008 and 2012: 2 wds. |
| 40% | PRINCEFIELDER | 13 | Rangers designated hitter who won the MLB Comeback Player of the Year Award in 2015: 2 wds. |
| 40% | DEREKJETER | 10 | Yankee shortstop who won the 1996 American League Rookie of the Year Award (2 wds.) |
| 40% | LUKADONCIC | 10 | 2019 NBA Rookie of the Year who was named to the NBA All-Star team three years in a row (2 wds.) |
| 40% | JENNIFERLOPEZ | 13 | "Let's Get Loud" singer who was named Glamour Woman of the Year in 1999 and 2011: 2 wds. |
| 39% | DREWBREES | 9 | Quarterback who was Sports Illustrated's 2010 Sportsman of the Year: 2 wds. |