| 100% | MINOSO | 6 | Nine-time baseball All-Star nicknamed "The Cuban Comet" |
| 46% | BIGMAC | 6 | Baseball All-Star's nickname ... or a popular food product |
| 45% | SOSA | 4 | Sammy ___, one of the most famous Baseball players of all time |
| 45% | SANTO | 5 | Ron ___, nine-time All-Star from the 1960s-'70s Cubs |
| 45% | TINATHOMPSON | 12 | Nine-time WNBA All-Star inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 2018 (2 wds.) |
| 43% | DAYANDNIGHT | 11 | All the time, as well as a hint to the abbreviations hidden in the starred answers |
| 43% | OTT | 3 | 12-time baseball All-Star |
| 42% | TREVORHOFFMAN | 13 | Seven-time MLB All-Star inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2018 (2 wds.) |
| 42% | MANNY | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star ___ Trillo |
| 42% | ALOMAR | 6 | Six-time baseball All-Star Sandy |
| 42% | REYES | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star Jose |
| 42% | STAUB | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Rusty |
| 42% | SOSA | 4 | Seven-time baseball All-Star Sammy |
| 42% | MAURY | 5 | Five-time baseball All-Star ___ Wills |
| 42% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time baseball All-Star Longoria |
| 42% | SOSA | 4 | Seven-time baseball All-Star Sammy ___ |
| 42% | UTLEY | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Chase |
| 42% | MANNY | 5 | Five-time baseball All-Star Machado |
| 42% | BRETT | 5 | 12-time baseball All-Star, 1976-88 |
| 42% | OTT | 3 | 12-time baseball All-Star, 1934-45 |
| 41% | SORRENTINO | 10 | Michael ___ ("Jersey Shore" star nicknamed The Situation) |
| 41% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star |
| 41% | ODOM | 4 | N.B.A. star nicknamed the Candy Man |
| 41% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star Bobby |
| 41% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star Bruin |
| 40% | JERRY | 5 | ___ West, 14-time NBA All-Star nicknamed "Mr. Clutch" who lost 8 of the 9 finals in which he played |
| 40% | OSCAR | 5 | 12-time NBA All-Star Robertson nicknamed "The Big O" |
| 40% | GIAMBI | 6 | Jason who's a five-time baseball All-Star |
| 40% | SOTO | 4 | Juan ___, three-time baseball All-Star from 2021-23 |
| 40% | YOST | 4 | Baseball's Eddie, 1952 All-Star for the Senators |