| 100% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star Bruin |
| 78% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star |
| 77% | ORR | 3 | Nine-time NHL All-Star Bobby |
| 61% | BRYANTROTTIER | 13 | Seven-time NHL All-Star |
| 60% | ILYA | 4 | Three-time NHL All-Star Kovalchuk |
| 60% | JAGR | 4 | 13-time NHL all-star Jaromir __ |
| 57% | STEPH | 5 | Nine-time NBA All-Star Curry, familiarly |
| 55% | MINOSO | 6 | Nine-time baseball All-Star nicknamed "The Cuban Comet" |
| 50% | SANTO | 5 | Ron ___, nine-time All-Star from the 1960s-'70s Cubs |
| 49% | ORR | 3 | Bruins' Bobby, only NHL defenseman to ever score nine hat tricks |
| 48% | ALEX | 4 | All-star NHL player Ovechkin |
| 48% | BOGART | 6 | American Film Institute's "greatest male star of all time" |
| 46% | TINATHOMPSON | 12 | Nine-time WNBA All-Star inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 2018 (2 wds.) |
| 46% | ORR | 3 | Bruins' NHL player who was the only defenceman to ever score nine hat tricks |
| 44% | CAREW | 5 | All-Star 18 consecutive times from 1967 to 1984 |
| 44% | BENITO | 6 | Five-time All Star catcher Santiago |
| 44% | KOBE | 4 | 4-time all star mvp bryant |
| 44% | DAYANDNIGHT | 11 | All the time, as well as a hint to the abbreviations hidden in the starred answers |
| 44% | NINETY | 6 | Nine times ten |
| 43% | SCHOFIELD | 9 | Kendall Coyne ___, first woman to compete in the NHL All-Star skills competition |
| 43% | JIMBUNNING | 10 | Nine-time MLB All-Star who served as U.S. representative and 21-Down from Kentucky from 1987 to 2011 (2 wds.) |
| 43% | NONUPLE | 7 | Nine times as large |
| 42% | EDDIESHORE | 10 | Boston Bruin who was the NHL's MVP four times from 1933 to 1938: 2 wds. |
| 42% | ASARULE | 7 | Nine times out of ten |
| 41% | CHUCK | 5 | ___ Taylor All Stars |
| 41% | KID | 3 | Robert James Ritchie, aka "___ Rock", entertainment headliner for the January 2018 NHL All-Star Game |
| 40% | MVP | 3 | Gretzky, nine times: Abbr. |
| 40% | MIKEBOSSY | 9 | NHL player with the all-time highest goals-per-game percentage |
| 40% | ETERNITY | 8 | All time |
| 39% | STYX | 4 | It circles Hades nine times |