| 100% | TWO | 3 | Number rhymed with "buckle my shoe" |
| 66% | ONE | 3 | "___, two, buckle my shoe..." (nursery rhyme) |
| 65% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe," popular nursery rhyme |
| 65% | TWO | 3 | "One, ___, buckle my shoe ..." (nursery rhyme starter) |
| 64% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe" (words from a rhyme) |
| 53% | TWO | 3 | "One, ___, buckle my shoe" |
| 53% | ONE | 3 | "____, two, Buckle my shoe" |
| 53% | ONE | 3 | "___, Two, Buckle My Shoe" |
| 51% | HEN | 3 | "One, Two, Buckle My Shoe" bird |
| 49% | ORR | 3 | Bobby whose jersey number rhymed with his surname |
| 49% | ORR | 3 | Hockey great whose jersey number rhymed with his name |
| 47% | BUCKLE | 6 | One, two __ my shoe, nursery rhyme |
| 46% | ATE | 3 | Word that rhymes with the number 8 |
| 46% | NATE | 4 | Man's name that rhymes with a number |
| 46% | STYX | 4 | Classic rock band that rhymes with a number |
| 45% | UNTO | 4 | Quaint word whose syllables rhyme with consecutive numbers |
| 45% | STRAIT | 6 | Country star whose last name rhymes with a number |
| 45% | PREVIN | 6 | Knighted orchestra conductor whose name rhymes with a number |
| 45% | NYRO | 4 | Singer-songwriter whose last name rhymes with a number |
| 44% | SLIPON | 6 | Shoe style with no laces or buckles |
| 43% | CLIVE | 5 | First name of a music mogul that rhymes with a number |
| 41% | TREE | 4 | "Cowboys Don't Cry" singer Oliver, whose last name rhymes with a number |
| 40% | YETI | 4 | ___ in My Spaghetti (children’s game with a rhyming name) |
| 40% | TINE | 4 | Fork prong that rhymes with "mine" |
| 37% | BUSTA | 5 | Rhymes with rhymes |
| 37% | RAP | 3 | Rhyme with rhythm |
| 35% | NDA | 3 | Billie Eilish song with the lyric "Didn't change my number, made him shut his mouth" |
| 35% | STRAP | 5 | Strip with buckle |
| 35% | SKIBOOT | 7 | Footwear with buckles |
| 34% | VANS | 4 | Skateboarding shoes manufacturer (rhymes with "cans") |