| 100% | MIRIAM | 6 | O. Henry Award-winning Truman Capote story, or either of its main female characters |
| 26% | OLSEN | 5 | O. Henry Award-winning author Tillie ___ |
| 26% | LIGHT | 5 | It can be the opposite of either dark or heavy |
| 25% | HEADCANON | 9 | Fan's unconfirmed interpretation of a character or story |
| 25% | OATES | 5 | O. Henry Award winner for "In the Region of Ice" (1967) and "The Dead" (1973) |
| 25% | HEROINE | 7 | Main female character |
| 25% | THEOLDGRAMMYMARE | 16 | Aged female horse that has won lots of singing awards? |
| 25% | MAGI | 4 | "The Gift of the ___," O. Henry story |
| 25% | OINK | 4 | It comes out of a pen, either with or without its first letter |
| 24% | MARIA | 5 | Lead character in "The Sound of Music" or "West Side Story" |
| 24% | MAGI | 4 | O. Henry's short story "The Gift of the ___" |
| 24% | BET | 3 | Teyana Taylor won Video Director of the Year at its 2020 award show |
| 24% | MAGI | 4 | "The Gift of the ___," story by O. Henry |
| 23% | ULEE | 4 | Character of a beekeeper played by Peter Fonda for which he won a Golden Globe Award |
| 23% | DOROTHEA | 8 | __ Brooke, Middlemarch's main female character |
| 23% | MINA | 4 | Harker, main female character in Dracula |
| 23% | ATLANTA | 7 | Award-winning Donald Glover TV series, or where it was filmed |
| 23% | NIKITA | 6 | The CW drama about a female spy (2010-2013), or the main character's first name |
| 23% | BRONZESTAR | 10 | Award won by Henry Fonda |
| 22% | ROO | 3 | The smallest of the main characters in the Winnie-the-Pooh stories |
| 22% | TAYLORSWIFT | 11 | "Love Story" singer-songwriter who won the award for Top Female Artist in Billboard 2018: 2 wds. |
| 22% | TAYLORSWIFT | 11 | "Lavender Haze" singer who won the People's Choice Award for Female Artist of 2022: 2 wds. |
| 22% | DANTESINFERNO | 13 | Its main characters go to hell |
| 22% | CHRON | 5 | Either of two O.T. books |
| 22% | STEPHENKING | 11 | "Carrie" author who won a 1996 O. Henry Award for his short story "The Man in the Black Suit": 2 wds. |
| 22% | HARRYSTYLES | 11 | "As It Was" singer who won the People's Choice Award for Male Artist of 2022: 2 wds. |
| 22% | ANNE | 4 | Either of two wives of Henry VIII |
| 22% | ANNE | 4 | Either of two of Henry's eight |
| 22% | XXX | 3 | Either of two for OK or OH |