| 100% | MRRED | 5 | Old baseball mascot with a "C" on his cap |
| 61% | NAT | 3 | Baseballer with a "W" on his cap |
| 54% | ASTRO | 5 | Baseball player with an H on his cap |
| 50% | WARIO | 5 | Nintendo antagonist with a "W" on his cap |
| 47% | PHANATIC | 8 | Baseball mascot with a fluffy green snout |
| 46% | MRMET | 5 | Mascot with a baseball head |
| 45% | NAT | 3 | Player with a curly W on his cap |
| 45% | REDS | 4 | Baseball team with a C logo |
| 44% | MRMET | 5 | N.Y.C. mascot with a baseball for a head |
| 43% | MRMET | 5 | N.L. mascot with a baseball head |
| 43% | SQUEEZEPLAY | 11 | Baseball tactic with a runner on third |
| 43% | METS | 4 | Baseball team with a baseball mascot |
| 42% | ATLAS | 5 | Someone with a lot on his shoulders |
| 42% | BIGEATER | 8 | Person with a lot on his plate? |
| 41% | ELROY | 5 | Toon with an antenna on his cap |
| 41% | ESSO | 4 | Old gas brand with a tiger mascot |
| 40% | POTTER | 6 | Wizard with a lightning bolt on his forehead |
| 40% | HARRYPOTTER | 11 | Character with a 37-Across on his forehead |
| 40% | PADRE | 5 | Ballplayer with "SD" on his cap |
| 40% | VISOR | 5 | Brim on a baseball cap |
| 39% | FREDDURST | 9 | Nu-metal artist with a trademark backward red baseball cap |
| 39% | ELROY | 5 | Cartoon boy with an antenna on his cap |
| 39% | STL | 3 | Letters on a Cardinals baseball cap |
| 39% | CAPITALA | 8 | Symbol on a Braves baseball cap |
| 39% | IPANA | 5 | Old toothpaste with a beaver mascot |
| 39% | PAWAHTUN | 8 | Maya god with a shell on his back, god of scribes |
| 39% | WIFEGUY | 7 | Dude with a social-media presence centered on his female spouse |
| 39% | KIDFLASH | 8 | Young DC Comics sidekick with a lightning bolt on his chest |
| 39% | LARDLADDONUTS | 13 | Pastry shop with a giant mascot, on "The Simpsons": 3 wds. |
| 39% | AFLAC | 5 | Company with a bird mascot on the Advertising Walk of Fame |