| 100% | OBLIVION | 8 | Old British cat finds four in neglect |
| 38% | RAJ | 3 | Old British rule in India |
| 37% | PUMA | 4 | Large cat found in Yellowstone |
| 37% | LION | 4 | Large cat found in Africa |
| 35% | SHILLING | 8 | Old British silver coin also used in its colonies |
| 35% | OCELOT | 6 | Medium-sized cat found in South America |
| 35% | APPLE | 5 | Fruit found four times in this puzzle |
| 35% | {PIE}PAN | 8 | Cookware found four times in this puzzle |
| 35% | HEP | 3 | In like an old cat? |
| 35% | RAJ | 3 | British rule in old India |
| 35% | CHEETAHS | 8 | Group of spotted cats found in a coalition |
| 35% | LEOPARDS | 8 | Big cats found in a leap or prowl |
| 34% | FRATERNITIES | 12 | Four groups found in this puzzle |
| 34% | COBWEB | 6 | Found in old and dusty places |
| 34% | FANG | 4 | Canine found in cats |
| 34% | MOG | 3 | Pet cat, in British lingo |
| 34% | NOB | 3 | Fat cat, in British slang |
| 34% | WOODLOUSE | 9 | Bug found in old timber |
| 34% | LEAD | 4 | Metal found in old paint |
| 33% | PRAYER | 6 | It ends with something found four times in this puzzle |
| 33% | COMPRESSEDFILES | 15 | Contents of some archives, found four times in this puzzle |
| 33% | SOCIALCLIMBER | 13 | Certain striver ... or something found four times in this puzzle? |
| 33% | LEGO | 4 | Brand of building bricks found four times in this puzzle |
| 33% | NUCLEAR | 7 | With 41-Across, massive reaction found four times in this puzzle |
| 33% | TSQUARE | 7 | Drafting tool, and a feature found four times in this puzzle |
| 33% | CRADLE | 6 | Oldest game in history, play with string, Cat's __ |
| 32% | CPAS | 4 | Summers found in the four longest answers |
| 32% | RUSTYNAIL | 9 | Something found in an old board, maybe |
| 32% | ASBESTOS | 8 | Dangerous fibers found in old building materials |
| 32% | COBWEBS | 7 | Spider byproducts often found in old houses |