| 100% | NAHUM | 5 | Old Testament figure who prophesied Nineveh's fall |
| 40% | ENOS | 4 | Old Testament figure |
| 40% | MOSES | 5 | Old Testament figure |
| 37% | ESAU | 4 | Old Testament figure whose name rhymes with "seesaw" |
| 37% | POTIPHAR | 8 | Old Testament captain of Pharaoh's guard who bought Joseph as a slave |
| 36% | ELI | 3 | Old Testament priest who taught Samuel |
| 35% | MOSES | 5 | Old Testament figure played by Charlton Heston in "The Ten Commandments" |
| 35% | HOSEA | 5 | Old Testament prophet who married a harlot |
| 35% | NOAH | 4 | Old Testament Hebrew patriarch who built an ark |
| 35% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 34% | JOAB | 4 | Old Testament army captain who put Absalom to death |
| 34% | JONAH | 5 | Old Testament prophet who was swallowed by a whale |
| 34% | HUMPTYDUMPTY | 12 | Nursery rhyme figure who fell to pieces |
| 33% | JOB | 3 | Old Testament prophet who lived in the land of Uz |
| 33% | JEREMIAH | 8 | Old Testament prophet to whom the Book of Lamentations is ascribed |
| 33% | NARCISSUS | 9 | Myth figure who fell in love with his reflection |
| 32% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet of the 9th-century BC who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 32% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet of the 9th century BC who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 32% | IDOL | 4 | Figure who's worshipped |
| 31% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived 905 years |
| 31% | SHEBA | 5 | Queen of __ (Old Testament figure) |
| 31% | SHEBA | 5 | Old Testament's Queen of __ |
| 31% | SHEBA | 5 | Old Testament's Queen of ___ |
| 31% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived for 905 years |
| 30% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived nine hundred and five years |
| 29% | HAGAR | 5 | Egyptian maid of Sarah in the Old Testament who was mother of Ishmael by Abraham |
| 29% | ENOS | 4 | Son of Seth in the Old Testament who lived for nine hundred and five years |
| 29% | MRCLEAN | 7 | Public figure who’s scandal-free |
| 29% | ELIOT | 5 | T. S. who wrote Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats |
| 28% | GIDEON | 6 | Hebrew judge in the Old Testament who led the Israelites to victory over their Midianite oppressors |