| 100% | JONAH | 5 | Old Testament prophet who was swallowed by a whale |
| 63% | JONAH | 5 | Biblical character who was swallowed by a whale |
| 51% | HOSEA | 5 | Old Testament prophet who married a harlot |
| 50% | JONAH | 5 | Prophet swallowed by a whale |
| 48% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | 1940 animated film in which the title character is swallowed by a whale named Monstro |
| 47% | JONAH | 5 | Biblical prophet swallowed by a whale |
| 47% | JEREMIAH | 8 | Old Testament prophet to whom the Book of Lamentations is ascribed |
| 43% | LADY | 4 | "There was an old ___ who swallowed a fly ... " |
| 42% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 42% | JONAH | 5 | Biblical figure swallowed by a whale |
| 42% | HAGAR | 5 | Egyptian maid of Sarah in the Old Testament who was mother of Ishmael by Abraham |
| 42% | JONAH | 5 | He was swallowed by a fish |
| 42% | ARK | 3 | Vessel built by a man who was at least five hundred years old, per Genesis |
| 41% | JONAH | 5 | He was swallowed by a great fish |
| 41% | AMOS | 4 | Prophet who was a shepherd |
| 41% | JOB | 3 | Old Testament prophet who lived in the land of Uz |
| 39% | JONAH | 5 | Prophet swallowed by a fish |
| 38% | JONAH | 5 | Prophet swallowed by a big fish |
| 38% | EARP | 4 | Old West lawman Wyatt who was played in a movie by Kevin Costner |
| 38% | LOSTINBEAGLE | 12 | Dramedy series about everything that's been swallowed by a dog like Snoopy? |
| 38% | ELIJAH | 6 | Biblical prophet who was fed by ravens |
| 38% | EVE | 3 | Woman who was tempted by a serpent |
| 38% | MENTEE | 6 | One who is guided by a mentor |
| 37% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet of the 9th-century BC who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 37% | ELIJAH | 6 | Old Testament prophet of the 9th century BC who denounced Ahab and Jezebel |
| 36% | EVE | 3 | Biblical woman who was tempted by a serpent |
| 36% | JONAH | 5 | Biblical prophet who had a whale of a time? |
| 35% | EVE | 3 | Woman who was tempted by a serpent in the Book of Genesis |
| 35% | SNOWDEN | 7 | Edward who was dubbed "The Dark Prophet" by Time magazine |
| 35% | POTIPHAR | 8 | Old Testament captain of Pharaoh's guard who bought Joseph as a slave |