| 100% | ALUM | 4 | One in the class of '12 or '13, now |
| 64% | ITEM | 4 | One of 12 or fewer, in the express lane |
| 53% | ITEM | 4 | One of 12 or less, in a supermarket express lane |
| 53% | TEAM | 4 | One of 12 in the WNBA |
| 52% | APOSTLE | 7 | One of 12 in the New Testament |
| 52% | SRS | 3 | The class of '13 in '13, e.g. |
| 52% | STAR | 4 | One of 12 in the European Union logo |
| 51% | AMONG | 5 | In the class of |
| 50% | BIAS | 4 | In the game of bowls, a bulge or weight inside one side of a bowl |
| 50% | ITEM | 4 | One of 10 or less in the express lane |
| 48% | SENIOR | 6 | One in the upper class |
| 48% | LEADDETECTIVES | 14 | Ones in charge of a case ... or a literal hint to the eight other longest answers in this puzzle |
| 48% | UTAH | 4 | One of the 12 in the Pac-12 |
| 48% | ALUM | 4 | Person in the class of '25, e.g. |
| 48% | ALIENS | 6 | One of the eggs used in this 1986 film is now exhibited at the Smithsonian |
| 48% | SNOOZER | 7 | One in the arms of Morpheus |
| 48% | VEE | 3 | One in the middle of Knoxville? |
| 47% | REASON | 6 | One of 13 in the popular Netflix title starring Katherine Langford |
| 47% | RUE | 3 | One of the 12 female tributes in "The Hunger Games" |
| 47% | REASON | 6 | One of the 13 in the popular Netflix title |
| 47% | TUTEE | 5 | One in a class of her own? |
| 47% | TUTEE | 5 | One in a class of her own |
| 47% | SOPHS | 5 | The class of '26 in '24, say |
| 47% | REF | 3 | One in the middle of a fight |
| 47% | ELEVE | 5 | One in the charge of un instituteur |
| 47% | BEBE | 4 | One in the care of una madre |
| 47% | GETOVERIT | 9 | Advice for the brokenhearted ... or one of four arrangements found literally in this puzzle |
| 47% | PROPHETS | 8 | Hosea is one of 12 minor __ in the Hebrew Bible |
| 46% | ROLE | 4 | One of 12 for Lily Tomlin in The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe |
| 46% | STAR | 4 | Betelgeuse is one in the news, right now |