| 100% | DEIST | 5 | One who does not believe in miracles |
| 77% | AGNOSTIC | 8 | One who does not believe nor disbelieve in a God |
| 66% | UNITARIAN | 9 | Christian who does not believe in the Trinity |
| 58% | SUNNI | 5 | One who believes Muhammad did not designate a successor |
| 54% | STOIC | 5 | One who does not exhibit emotions |
| 52% | GOD | 3 | What an atheist does not believe in |
| 49% | DEIST | 5 | Believer who doesn't believe in miracles |
| 49% | COPILOT | 7 | One who's not fully in control |
| 49% | NERD | 4 | One who's not in |
| 49% | HINDU | 5 | One who believes in karma |
| 49% | RASTA | 5 | One who believes in Jah |
| 49% | ATHEIST | 7 | One who doesn't believe in a deity |
| 49% | PAGAN | 5 | One who believes in many gods |
| 49% | ANIMIST | 7 | One who believes in nature spirits |
| 48% | ATHEIST | 7 | One who doesn't believe in God or gods |
| 48% | CHILD | 5 | One who may believe in 27-Across |
| 48% | TROOFER | 7 | One who believes conspiracy theories, not facts |
| 48% | OUTSIDER | 8 | One who’s not in the loop |
| 47% | PSALM | 5 | The first one begins "Blessed is the one who does not walk in step with the wicked" |
| 47% | DOER | 4 | One who believes more in action than talk |
| 47% | OCEANDEIST | 10 | One who believes exclusively in a sea god? |
| 47% | HIDER | 5 | One who's not "it," in a kid's game |
| 47% | DWEEB | 5 | One who's definitely not in the in-crowd |
| 47% | EGOTIST | 7 | One who believes there is an "I" in "team"? |
| 46% | CAMERON | 7 | British PM David, who did not support Brexit and resigned in 2016 |
| 46% | ALMICHAELS | 10 | Sportscaster who memorably asked "Do you believe in miracles?" |
| 46% | DOLT | 4 | One who’s not the sharpest tool in the shed |
| 46% | RIPLEY | 6 | Cartoonist Robert ___ who founded the franchise which deals in bizarre events and items one may or may not be able to believe |
| 45% | LAYWOMAN | 8 | One who's not in the habit of wearing a habit |
| 45% | MOM | 3 | One who tells you to not roll around in the dirt, maybe |