| 100% | RANDY | 5 | Original "American Idol" judge Jackson |
| 94% | RANDY | 5 | Longtime American Idol judge Jackson |
| 75% | PAULA | 5 | Original "American Idol" judge Abdul |
| 72% | SIMON | 5 | Original "American Idol" judge with Randy and Paula |
| 66% | ABDUL | 5 | Paula the American Idol judge |
| 65% | RANDY | 5 | Jackson who was an "American Idol" judge |
| 60% | SIMONCOWELL | 11 | An American Idol judge known for his cutting remarks: 2 wds. |
| 55% | JENNIFERLOPEZ | 13 | An American idol judge who starred in movies such as "Maid in Manhattan": 2 wds. |
| 55% | SIMON | 5 | "American Idol" judge |
| 55% | ABDUL | 5 | "American Idol" judge |
| 54% | KARA | 4 | "American Idol" judge DioGuardi |
| 54% | LOPEZ | 5 | "American Idol" judge Jennifer |
| 54% | TYLER | 5 | "American Idol" judge Steven |
| 54% | PAULA | 5 | "American Idol" judge ___ Abdul |
| 54% | LUKE | 4 | "American Idol" judge ___ Bryan |
| 54% | KATY | 4 | "American Idol" judge Perry |
| 53% | ABDUL | 5 | Former "American Idol" judge |
| 53% | PAULAABDUL | 10 | Former "American Idol" judge |
| 53% | LUKE | 4 | ___ Bryan, "American Idol" judge |
| 52% | EACHRANDY | 9 | *Every person named like NFL receiver Moss, "American Idol" judge Jackson, composer Newman, etc.? |
| 52% | PRODIGALSIMON | 13 | "American Idol" judge who wastes money? |
| 52% | SIMON | 5 | Sharp-tongued "American Idol" judge |
| 52% | STEVEN | 6 | Former "American Idol" judge Tyler |
| 52% | KARA | 4 | Former "American Idol" judge DioGuardi |
| 52% | ABDUL | 5 | Former "American Idol" judge Paula |
| 52% | PAULA | 5 | Former "American Idol" judge Abdul |
| 52% | URBAN | 5 | Former "American Idol" judge Keith |
| 52% | COWELL | 6 | Former "American Idol" judge Simon |
| 52% | PAULA | 5 | 2000s "American Idol" judge Abdul |
| 52% | KARA | 4 | ___ DioGuardi, former "American Idol" judge |