| 100% | HYPHENS | 7 | Pair of punctuation marks in the word "merry-go-round" |
| 58% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "good-looking" |
| 58% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "two-faced" |
| 47% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark that might appear many times in a long list of words |
| 46% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in the title "I, Tonya" |
| 44% | APOSTROPHE | 10 | Punctuation mark in the "Paradise City" rock band's name |
| 43% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in a list of items |
| 43% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "Honey, I Shrunk the Kids" |
| 43% | OMEARA | 6 | Mark in the World Golf Hall of Fame |
| 43% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the "What's My Age Again?" rock band's name |
| 42% | TILDE | 5 | Mark in the intersection of 56-Across and 38-Down |
| 42% | CEDILLA | 7 | Mark in the intersection of 58-Across and 43-Down |
| 42% | UMLAUT | 6 | Mark in the intersection of 17-Across and 1-Down |
| 42% | CIRCUMFLEX | 10 | Mark in the intersection of 19-Across and 11-Down |
| 41% | PERIODS | 7 | Punctuation marks at the end of statements |
| 40% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark representing the eyes in an emoticon |
| 40% | PERIOD | 6 | Punctuation mark at the end of a sentence |
| 40% | ANTONYMS | 8 | Pairs of words that are opposite in meaning |
| 40% | UMLAUTS | 7 | Pairs of dots, in some German words |
| 40% | STONE | 5 | Piece in the game of go |
| 40% | SCAR | 4 | Mark in the shape of a lightning bolt on Harry Potter's forehead |
| 40% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that forms the eyes in many emoticons |
| 40% | TAGTEAM | 7 | Pair of wrestlers who take turns in the ring |
| 40% | RSTLNE | 6 | Letters shown in the "Wheel of Fortune" bonus round |
| 40% | GARTERINN | 9 | Tavern in The Merry Wives of Windsor |
| 40% | MISS | 4 | Go wide of the mark |
| 40% | CENTERLINE | 10 | Marking in the middle of the road ... or an alternate title for this puzzle |
| 39% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark often used to separate words in a list |
| 39% | KIDNEYS | 7 | Pair of organs in the body that filter the blood |
| 39% | TONSILS | 7 | Pair of soft tissue lumps in back of the throat |