| 100% | SICILIA | 7 | Palermo’s island, to the locals |
| 65% | WIEN | 4 | Austria's capital, to the locals |
| 65% | LISBOA | 6 | Portugal's capital, to the locals |
| 62% | SICILIA | 7 | 20-Across's island, to locals |
| 58% | ROMA | 4 | Capital of Italy, to the locals |
| 57% | EIRE | 4 | Ireland, to the locals |
| 56% | MAUI | 4 | Closest island to the Big Island |
| 55% | MAURITIUS | 9 | Tiny island to the East of Madagascar |
| 54% | CANIBUYAVOW | 11 | Request to the local marriage oath writer? |
| 54% | IOS | 3 | Island said to be the home of Homer's tomb |
| 54% | IBIZA | 5 | Island home to the world's biggest nightclub |
| 54% | SAKHALIN | 8 | Long Russian island to the north of Japan |
| 54% | FAROE | 5 | Danish islands to the north west of Scotland |
| 53% | ALOHA | 5 | "Welcome to the islands" |
| 53% | ALOHA | 5 | "Welcome to the Islands!" |
| 53% | KAVA | 4 | Medicinal plant native to the Pacific islands that's used to treat stress |
| 53% | GREENLAND | 9 | Arctic island said to be the world's largest |
| 53% | KRITI | 5 | Largest Greek island, to locals |
| 53% | MENORCA | 7 | Mediterranean resort island, to locals |
| 53% | MALLORCA | 8 | Spanish resort island, to locals |
| 53% | MENORCA | 7 | Spanish resort island, to locals |
| 52% | TAIPEI | 6 | Island capital with the world's tallest building from 2004 to 2010 |
| 51% | MAJORCAN | 8 | Relating to the largest Balearic island |
| 51% | CRETAN | 6 | Relating to the largest Greek island |
| 51% | MENORCA | 7 | Spanish island, to locals |
| 51% | BLUEFOOTEDBOOBY | 15 | Seabird native to the Galápagos Islands |
| 51% | ACT | 3 | Alternative to the S.A.T. |
| 51% | OAHU | 4 | Island home to the only royal palace in the U.S. |
| 51% | KOMODO | 6 | Island that's home to the world's largest lizard |
| 51% | KEY | 3 | ___ to the city (gift for a local hero) |