| 100% | MINTCONDITION | 13 | Perfect shape, to a collector |
| 64% | RARER | 5 | More valuable to a collector |
| 64% | RAREST | 6 | Most interesting to a collector |
| 63% | MINT | 4 | Flawless, to a collector |
| 62% | RARER | 5 | More desirable, to a collector |
| 62% | RAREST | 6 | Most valuable, to a collector |
| 59% | RARE | 4 | Desirable to a collector, say |
| 59% | RARE | 4 | Of interest to a collector, say |
| 59% | MINT | 4 | In top condition, to a collector |
| 59% | MINT | 4 | In pristine condition, to a collector |
| 57% | TEN | 3 | Perfect score to a gymnast |
| 56% | TENSE | 5 | Perfect, to a syntactician |
| 54% | SET | 3 | What a collector wants to complete |
| 54% | CONIC | 5 | Relating to a certain geometric shape |
| 54% | OLAV | 4 | Name that anagrams to a shape |
| 53% | FINER | 5 | In better condition, to a coin collector |
| 53% | EDITION | 7 | Detail of interest to a book collector |
| 53% | TEE | 3 | "It fits to a ___" ("It's perfect!") |
| 53% | SNOWMAN | 7 | Snow shaped to resemble a human figure |
| 53% | ASSET | 5 | Perfect pitch, to a singer |
| 53% | TEN | 3 | Perfect score, to a gymnast |
| 53% | ORB | 3 | Celestial shape, to a poet |
| 52% | RARES | 5 | Hardest-to-find items to a collector |
| 52% | MORE | 4 | "... to form a ___ perfect union ..." |
| 51% | MATEFORLIFE | 11 | Pirate captain's offer to a board game collector? |
| 51% | WRITEOFFTHEBAT | 14 | Advice from an accountant to a baseball memorabilia collector? |
| 51% | INLAYS | 6 | Fillings that are shaped to fit a damaged tooth |
| 51% | NEARMINT | 8 | Almost as good as new, to a comic-book collector |
| 50% | PEAR | 4 | Orchard fruit that lends its name to a body shape |
| 50% | SCOOPER | 7 | Collector next to a litter box |