| 100% | IGUANA | 6 | Pet that can regrow its tail |
| 59% | SEAHORSE | 8 | Fish that can twine its tail |
| 59% | SKINK | 5 | Lizard that can shed its tail |
| 54% | LIZARD | 6 | Animal that can detach its tail to escape danger |
| 52% | GECKO | 5 | Lizard that can detach its own tail |
| 48% | CAT | 3 | Pet that can hiss |
| 47% | CAT | 3 | Pet that can be polydactyl |
| 46% | CAT | 3 | Pet that can be toilet trained |
| 45% | NEWT | 4 | Amphibian that can regrow an appendage |
| 44% | PARROT | 6 | Pet that can imitate human speech and other sounds |
| 43% | GOLDFISH | 8 | Small aquatic pet that can live for many years |
| 42% | SKINK | 5 | Lizard that may shed its tail |
| 41% | RAT | 3 | Pest that can be a pet |
| 41% | FIRE | 4 | Emoji that can mean "Killing it!" |
| 41% | ALLIGATORS | 10 | Creatures that can regrow a lost tooth up to 50 times |
| 41% | ATE | 3 | You shouldn't be surprised that it could be up to a year since your pet anaconda last did this |
| 41% | SEALION | 7 | Animal that can run using its flippers |
| 41% | FLEA | 4 | Flightless insect that can bother a pet |
| 40% | LAPDOG | 6 | Canine pet that enjoys sitting on its owner |
| 40% | CROCODILE | 9 | Reptile that can't stick its tongue out |
| 40% | WIKI | 4 | Website that can be edited by its users |
| 40% | SEE | 3 | Verb that can combine with its past tense |
| 40% | ANT | 3 | Bug that can lift many times its weight |
| 40% | OTTER | 5 | Playful animal that can float on its back |
| 40% | GECKO | 5 | Lizard that could be a pet for some |
| 40% | MANTIS | 6 | Insect that can turn its head |
| 40% | EEL | 3 | Fish that can shock its prey |
| 40% | GRO | 3 | Skele-___, a terrible tasting medicinal potion that can regrow missing or removed bones |
| 40% | CAT | 3 | Pet that might clean itself with its leg in the air |
| 39% | ANT | 3 | Insect that can lift many times its own weight |