| 100% | PICKLED | 7 | Peter Piper picked a peck of __ peppers |
| 85% | PEES | 4 | Repeated things in "Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 84% | PEPPERS | 7 | Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled __ |
| 84% | PEES | 4 | What "Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" has a lot of |
| 82% | PETER | 5 | "___ Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 78% | PIPER | 5 | Peter who picked a peck of pickled peppers |
| 72% | PIPER | 5 | "Peter ___ picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 72% | PIPER | 5 | "Peter ___ picked a peck of pickled peppers..." |
| 72% | PECK | 4 | "Peter Piper picked a ___ of pickled peppers" |
| 71% | PETER | 5 | Piper who picked a peck of pickled peppers, in a tongue twister |
| 65% | PEE | 3 | Prominent part of "Peter Piper picked a peck..." |
| 62% | TONGUETWISTER | 13 | "Peter Piper picked a peck..." for one |
| 55% | PECK | 4 | Quantity of pickled peppers Peter Piper picked |
| 49% | PETER | 5 | Picker of a peck of pickled peppers |
| 38% | GREGORY | 7 | Peck of ''To Kill a Mockingbird'' |
| 36% | IDED | 4 | Picked out of a lineup |
| 36% | IDENTIFIED | 10 | Picked out of a lineup |
| 36% | SPOT | 4 | Pick out of a crowd |
| 36% | IDS | 3 | Picks out of a lineup |
| 36% | IDENTIFY | 8 | Pick out of a lineup |
| 36% | IDING | 5 | Picking out of a lineup |
| 35% | IDED | 4 | Picked out of a lineup, informally |
| 35% | IDED | 4 | Picked out of a lineup, briefly |
| 35% | IDS | 3 | Picks out of a lineup, briefly |
| 35% | IDS | 3 | Picks out of a lineup, informally |
| 35% | IDING | 5 | Picking out of a lineup, informally |
| 35% | IDS | 3 | Picks out of a mug book |
| 35% | IDS | 3 | Picks out of a lineup, say |
| 35% | IDED | 4 | Picked out of a lineup, for short |
| 35% | ROGET | 5 | Peter who compiled a book of synonyms |