| 100% | PETER | 5 | Picker of a peck of pickled peppers |
| 77% | PIPER | 5 | "Peter ___ picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 77% | PIPER | 5 | "Peter ___ picked a peck of pickled peppers..." |
| 77% | PETER | 5 | "___ Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 76% | PIPER | 5 | Peter who picked a peck of pickled peppers |
| 76% | PETER | 5 | Piper who picked a peck of pickled peppers |
| 74% | PEES | 4 | Repeated things in "Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 73% | PETER | 5 | Say this thrice without fumbling! "___ Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" |
| 73% | PETER | 5 | Piper who picked a peck of pickled peppers, in a tongue twister |
| 73% | PEES | 4 | What "Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" has a lot of |
| 70% | PETER | 5 | Say this thrice without fumbling! "___ Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers" (Spider-Man's alter-ego) |
| 61% | PEPPERS | 7 | Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled __ |
| 59% | PICKLED | 7 | Peter Piper picked a peck of __ peppers |
| 57% | PECK | 4 | "Peter Piper picked a ___ of pickled peppers" |
| 57% | PECK | 4 | "Peter Piper picked a ___ of pickled peppers..." |
| 46% | PETER | 5 | Pickled pepper picker |
| 46% | HENS | 4 | Members of a pecking order? |
| 46% | HEN | 3 | Part of a pecking order? |
| 44% | PECK | 4 | Quantity of pickled peppers Peter Piper picked |
| 44% | RED | 3 | Color of a fully ripe bell pepper |
| 43% | GREGORY | 7 | Peck of ''To Kill a Mockingbird'' |
| 43% | PAPRIKA | 7 | Powdered spice made from a variety of red pepper |
| 42% | RATATAT | 7 | Sound of a woodpecker pecking |
| 42% | SALTCELLAR | 10 | Partner of a pepper mill |
| 42% | GINGERLYSPICE | 13 | Add just a dash of pepper? |
| 40% | PEE | 3 | Prominent part of "Peter Piper picked a peck..." |
| 40% | STORK | 5 | Bird mascot on a jar of Vlasic pickles |
| 40% | PIBB | 4 | Mr. __: Former name of a Dr Pepper rival |
| 40% | SCOVILLE | 8 | Measure of a pepper's hotness: __ Heat Index |
| 40% | TATS | 4 | Red Hot Chili Peppers have a lot of them |