| 100% | TAPIR | 5 | Pig-like South American animal with a short trunk |
| 67% | TAPIR | 5 | South American mammal resembling a pig with a short trunk |
| 60% | COATI | 5 | South American animal with a snout |
| 60% | TAPIR | 5 | South American animal with a distinctive snout |
| 59% | TAPIR | 5 | Pig-like herbivore with a short trunk |
| 54% | ALPACA | 6 | South American animal that's like a small llama |
| 53% | LLAMA | 5 | South American animal whose name begins with a double letter |
| 51% | CAVY | 4 | South American short-tailed rodent with a stocky body |
| 48% | TAPIR | 5 | Animal that looks like a pig/anteater hybrid (rhymes with "vapor") |
| 47% | TAPIR | 5 | Animal with a trunk |
| 46% | ELEPHANT | 8 | Animal with a long trunk |
| 46% | ELEPHANT | 8 | Animal with a trunk and tusks |
| 46% | ROO | 3 | Animal with a pouch, for short |
| 45% | ORINOCO | 7 | South American river with a crocodile namesake |
| 45% | TITI | 4 | South American monkey with a reduplicating name |
| 45% | TAPIR | 5 | South American mammal with a prehensile snout |
| 45% | COATI | 5 | South American mammal with a flexible snout |
| 45% | LIONMONKEY | 10 | South American marmoset with a tufted tail |
| 45% | MARSUPIAL | 9 | Animal with a pouch, like a kangaroo |
| 45% | HIPPO | 5 | Animal with a scary yawn, for short |
| 45% | ELEPHANT | 8 | Big animal with a trunk |
| 44% | ACAI | 4 | South American palm with a black-purple berry |
| 44% | TAPIRS | 6 | Pig-like mammals with short nose trunks |
| 44% | TAPIR | 5 | Herbivore with a short prehensile trunk |
| 44% | LLAMA | 5 | South American animal that's a source of wool |
| 44% | CHILE | 5 | South American country with a 4,000-mile coastline |
| 44% | PERU | 4 | South American country with a red-and-white flag |
| 44% | PERU | 4 | South American country with the shortest name |
| 44% | ROO | 3 | Australian animal with a pouch, for short |
| 44% | ROO | 3 | Large animal with a pouch, for short |