| 100% | SMEE | 4 | Pirate that Neverpedia calls "an oddly genial man" |
| 33% | PAC | 3 | "___-Man," game that was originally called "Puck Man" |
| 32% | STU | 3 | Man's name that's an alphabetic string |
| 32% | STU | 3 | Man's name that's an alphabet run |
| 32% | STU | 3 | Man's nickname that's an alphabetic run |
| 32% | OTTO | 4 | Man's name that's an Italian number |
| 32% | RAIN | 4 | Shower that calls for an umbrella? |
| 32% | ARI | 3 | Man's name that's an investment spelled backward |
| 32% | LLOYD | 5 | Man's name that's an anagram of DOLLY |
| 32% | NIGEL | 5 | Man's name that's an anagram of ELGIN |
| 32% | ELIAS | 5 | Man's name that is an anagram of AISLE |
| 32% | AIDAN | 5 | Man's name that is an anagram of "Diana" |
| 32% | PRANK | 5 | Call that may result in an abrupt hang-up |
| 32% | TAMPA | 5 | City that hosts an annual Pirate Festival |
| 32% | RAINY | 5 | Like weather that calls for an umbrella |
| 31% | SMEE | 4 | Barrie's "oddly genial man" |
| 31% | ARLO | 4 | Man's name that's an anagram of 108-Down |
| 31% | ELI | 3 | Man's name that's an anagram of 63-Across |
| 30% | OUIJA | 5 | "Spirit board" that uses an accessory called a planchette |
| 30% | UBER | 4 | App that's an alternative to calling a cab |
| 30% | BALK | 4 | Infraction that an umpire might call on a pitcher |
| 30% | EDITORIAL | 9 | Newspaper piece that's an anagram of "real idiot", oddly |
| 30% | DONNE | 5 | John, poet who wrote that no man is an island |
| 30% | AARON | 5 | Name that might come first during an alphabetical roll call |
| 30% | EIRE | 4 | Country name that has an accent called a síneadh fada |
| 30% | PILATES | 7 | Class that might begin with an exercise called the hundred |
| 30% | OMAHA | 5 | U.S. city that Peyton Manning used as an audible |
| 29% | IMRE | 4 | Hungarian man's name that's an anagram of 38-Down |
| 29% | DEN | 3 | Room that might be called a man cave or she shed |
| 29% | KRAFT | 5 | Food giant that released an app called Big Fork Little Fork |