| 100% | TUG | 3 | Pitcher McGraw who is singer Tim McGraw's father |
| 65% | TUG | 3 | Former pitcher ___ McGraw, country singer Tim McGraw's father |
| 60% | TUG | 3 | Pitcher who was country star Tim McGraw's dad |
| 52% | ALAN | 4 | Actor Thicke who is singer Robin's father |
| 52% | ALAN | 4 | Performer Thicke who is singer Robin's father |
| 50% | FAITHHILL | 9 | Country singer who's married to singer Tim McGraw: 2 wds. |
| 48% | NATKINGCOLE | 11 | Legendary singer who was 18-Across's father: 3 wds. |
| 44% | TUG | 3 | Singer Tim McGraw's baseball-playing dad |
| 43% | ALAN | 4 | Actor Thicke who was the father of singer Robin |
| 43% | FAITHHILL | 9 | Country singer who stars with Tim McGraw and Sam Elliott on "1883" (2 wds.) |
| 42% | GEORGEVI | 8 | Monarch who was Queen Elizabeth II's father |
| 42% | RAVI | 4 | Sitar virtuoso Shankar who is the father of singer Norah Jones |
| 42% | ROB | 3 | Comedian Schneider who is singer Elle King's dad |
| 41% | TAYLORSWIFT | 11 | "Bad Blood" singer who has a song named after Tim McGraw: 2 wds. |
| 40% | ONO | 3 | Singer Yoko who was Lennon's love |
| 40% | SAL | 3 | Pitcher Maglie who was outdueled in Don Larsen's 1956 perfect game |
| 40% | SEAL | 4 | Singer who is Heidi Klum's ex-husband |
| 40% | ERMA | 4 | Singer Franklin who was Aretha's elder sister |
| 39% | MONAE | 5 | Singer Janelle who was featured on Fun's "We Are Young" |
| 39% | YOKO | 4 | Singer/artist Ono who is Sean Lennon's mother |
| 39% | DARTH | 5 | ___ Vader who is Luke Skywalker's father |
| 39% | RAVI | 4 | Shankar who was Norah Jones's father |
| 39% | TUG | 3 | With 48-Down, former pitcher whose son Tim is a country singer |
| 39% | SOLANGE | 7 | ___ Knowles, "Cranes in the Sky" singer who is singer Beyonce's sister |
| 38% | RAVI | 4 | Sitarist Shankar who is Norah Jones's father |
| 38% | ODIN | 4 | Norse mythological figure who is Thor's father |
| 38% | USHER | 5 | "Yeah!" singer who was Justin Bieber's mentor |
| 38% | MILEY | 5 | Singer Cyrus who is a coach on NBC's "The Voice" |
| 38% | TIM | 3 | Country singer McGraw who's married to Faith Hill |
| 38% | ANKA | 4 | Paul who is Jason Bateman's father-in-law |