| 100% | AUNTIEMAME | 10 | Play for which Peggy Cass won a Tony in 1957 |
| 53% | THERITZ | 7 | Play for which 59-Across won a Tony, 1975 |
| 53% | TRU | 3 | Play for which Robert Morse won a Tony and a Drama Desk Award |
| 52% | TRU | 3 | Play for which Robert Morse won a Best Actor Tony |
| 50% | CYRANO | 6 | Title role for which Christopher Plummer won a Tony in 1974 |
| 50% | LESLIE | 6 | He won a Tony for playing Aaron in Hamilton |
| 49% | FAITHP | 6 | She won a Tony for playing Miss Adelaide in "Guys and Dolls" |
| 48% | ODOM | 4 | Leslie ___, Jr. (actor who won a Tony award for playing Aaron Burr in "Hamilton") |
| 47% | VIOLADAVIS | 10 | Actress who won a Tony and an Oscar for playing Rose Maxson in "Fences": 2 wds. |
| 46% | YULBRYNNER | 10 | Actor who won a Tony and an Oscar for playing King Mongkut in "The King and I": 2 wds. |
| 45% | ANNEBANCROFT | 12 | Actress who won a Tony and an Oscar for playing Helen Keller's teacher in "The Miracle Worker": 2 wds. |
| 44% | JAMESEARLJONES | 14 | First Black performer to win a Tony Award for Lead Actor in a Play, for "The Great White Hope" in 1969: 3 wds. |
| 44% | BARNUM | 6 | Show for which Jim Dale won the 1980 Tony for Best Actor in a Musical |
| 44% | PHYLICIARASHAD | 14 | First Black performer to win a Tony Award for Lead Actress in a Play, for "A Raisin in the Sun" in 2004: 2 wds. |
| 43% | PIPPIN | 6 | Musical for which Ben Vereen won a Tony |
| 42% | HELLODOLLY | 10 | Broadway show for which 30-Across won the 1964 Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical (2 wds.) |
| 42% | KILEY | 5 | Richard who won a Tony for playing Don Quixote |
| 42% | LEN | 3 | Cariou who won a Tony for playing Sweeney Todd |
| 42% | GRIMES | 6 | Actress Tammy who won a Tony for playing Molly Brown |
| 42% | RUEHL | 5 | Actress Mercedes who won a Tony for “Lost in Yonkers” |
| 42% | ALEX | 4 | Newell who won a Tony for their role in “Shucked” |
| 42% | SARAHPAULSON | 12 | "American Horror Story" actress who won the 2024 Best Leading Actress in a Play Tony for "Appropriate": 2 wds. |
| 41% | IAMACAMERA | 10 | Play for which Julie Harris won the 1952 Tony for Best Actress |
| 41% | JEREMYSTRONG | 12 | "Succession" actor who won the 2024 Best Leading Actor in a Play Tony for "An Enemy of the People": 2 wds. |
| 41% | DAVIS | 5 | Viola who won both a Tony and an Oscar for playing Rose Maxson in “Fences” |
| 41% | DAVIDALANGRIER | 14 | "A Soldier's Play" actor who won the 2020 Tony Award for Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Play (3 wds.) |
| 40% | KUSHNER | 7 | Tony who won a Tony for "Angels in America" |
| 40% | THEACT | 6 | Show for which Liza Minnelli won a 1978 Tony |
| 40% | DANCIN | 6 | Show for which Bob Fosse won a 1978 Tony |
| 40% | THEACT | 6 | Musical for which Liza Minnelli won a 1978 Tony |