| 100% | BALI | 4 | Popular 'paradise' island |
| 78% | ARUBA | 5 | Popular Caribbean island |
| 69% | OAHU | 4 | Island popular with tourists |
| 67% | BALI | 4 | Popular island destination in Indonesia |
| 65% | MYST | 4 | Popular game set on an island |
| 65% | BALI | 4 | Popular holiday island east of Java |
| 65% | CATAN | 5 | Island in a popular board game |
| 65% | BALI | 4 | Popular Indonesian island (anagram of "bail") |
| 65% | TAHITI | 6 | Gauguin's island paradise |
| 62% | JAVA | 4 | Popular programming language which is also an island |
| 62% | OAHU | 4 | Island whose North Shore is popular with surfers |
| 61% | PHUKET | 6 | Large Thai island, internationally popular resort |
| 61% | TAHITI | 6 | South Pacific island popular with vacationers |
| 61% | KERAMA | 6 | Japanese island park popular with divers |
| 61% | BARBADOS | 8 | Caribbean island country popular with tourists |
| 60% | MALDIVES | 8 | Indian Ocean island republic popular with tourists |
| 60% | BALI | 4 | Indonesian island, popular with surfers and divers |
| 59% | PHI | 3 | When repeated, Thai islands popular with tourists |
| 58% | PHUKET | 6 | Popular Thai island known for Patong Beach and lively resorts |
| 58% | BERMUDACIRCLE | 13 | Close-knit group at a popular island destination? |
| 57% | ARUBA | 5 | Island whose name rhymes with a popular thing to do there |
| 55% | AVALON | 6 | Island paradise in Celtic mythology where King Arthur was taken after death |
| 55% | MYST | 4 | Popular early computer game that plopped you on a foggy, ___erious island |
| 50% | LONG | 4 | ___ Island, island in New York State that lends its name to a popular cocktail |
| 47% | TEA | 3 | "Long Island Iced ___" (popular drink) |
| 47% | ICED | 4 | Long island ___ tea (popular cocktail) |
| 47% | LONG | 4 | ___ Island Iced Tea, popular cocktail which is also named after the island in Southeast New York |
| 44% | RHODE | 5 | __ Island |
| 44% | CONEY | 5 | __ Island |
| 44% | ELLIS | 5 | __ Island |