| 100% | SILICONE | 8 | Popular rubber-like baking material that can bend |
| 42% | ELASTIC | 7 | Material that can be stretched |
| 42% | DENIM | 5 | Material that can be distressed |
| 42% | ORE | 3 | Material that can be smelted |
| 41% | ORE | 3 | Material that could come from a quarry |
| 40% | CLAY | 4 | Material that can be sculpted with the hands |
| 40% | ROCK | 4 | Material that could be igneous, metamorphic, or sedimentary |
| 40% | CLAY | 4 | Muddy material that can be molded |
| 39% | SILICONE | 8 | Rubbery material that can withstand high heat |
| 39% | INK | 3 | Writing material that could leave a blot |
| 39% | WOOL | 4 | Sweater material that could make you itch |
| 39% | TIN | 3 | Material that "cries" when bent |
| 39% | WAX | 3 | Material that can build up on floors or inside ears |
| 39% | DNA | 3 | Material that can be analyzed from a mouth swab: Abbr. |
| 38% | HEMP | 4 | Camp bracelet material that can't be smoked |
| 38% | FLAKY | 5 | Like baked items that crumble easily |
| 38% | NET | 3 | Mesh material that can keep mosquitoes away from campers |
| 38% | TAPEMEASURE | 11 | Rule that can be bent |
| 37% | MUFFIN | 6 | Baked product that can be English or American |
| 37% | OUTRAGE | 7 | Ire that can spread like wildfire |
| 37% | ASPHALT | 7 | Material that can be used to secure plant graftings and seal tree wounds |
| 37% | DNA | 3 | Genetic material that can be extracted from hair or saliva: Abbr. |
| 37% | METAL | 5 | Scrap ___ (iron or copper, e.g.), material that can be recycled |
| 36% | WRAP | 4 | Bubble ___, packing material that you can pop |
| 36% | SATIABLE | 8 | Like an appetite that can be fulfilled |
| 36% | HANDHELD | 8 | Like something lightweight that can be carried |
| 36% | LIZARDS | 7 | Reptiles that can be green, like chameleons |
| 36% | FONDANT | 7 | Icing that can be molded like clay |
| 36% | EDITABLE | 8 | Like a document that can be changed |
| 36% | AGILE | 5 | Like a mind that can solve crosswords |