| 100% | IMNOT | 5 | Possible response to "Who's coming with me into the haunted house?" |
| 45% | IDO | 3 | Possible response to "Who wants to solve a crossword with me?" |
| 42% | IAM | 3 | Possible response to "Are you with me?" |
| 38% | IDID | 4 | Possible response to "Who took the last cookie?" |
| 38% | REGINABELLE | 11 | "Baby Come to Me" singer who collaborated with 44-Across on the R&B hits "Without You" and 34-Across (2 wds.) |
| 38% | IDID | 4 | Possible response to "Who left dishes in the sink?" |
| 38% | IATEIT | 6 | Possible response to "Where's the beef?" |
| 37% | DITTO | 5 | The White House's Jessica, who in 2018 was found to have violated the Hatch Act with political tweets |
| 36% | IAM | 3 | Possible response to "Who's hungry?" |
| 36% | ITSME | 5 | Possible response to "Who's there?" |
| 36% | WEARE | 5 | Possible response to "Who's ready?" |
| 36% | IAM | 3 | Possible response to "Who's hungry?" (2 wds.) |
| 36% | YESYOU | 6 | Response to the question "Who, me?": 2 wds. |
| 35% | PESTO | 5 | Possible answer to the question “What should I make with all this basil?” |
| 35% | MYLIFE | 6 | Billy Joel hit with the line "I don't want you to tell me it's time to come home" |
| 35% | BALIHAI | 7 | Show tune with the repeated line "Come to me, come to me!" |
| 35% | DEFDOGNIGHT | 11 | Band with the 1970 #1 hit "Mama Told Me (Not to Come)" |
| 35% | IAM | 3 | Possible response to "Who's hungry for cake?" (2 wds.) |
| 35% | IAM | 3 | Possible response to "Who's ready for cake?" (2 wds.) |
| 35% | BERRA | 5 | Yankee Yogi who's credited with saying "When you come to a fork in the road, take it" |
| 34% | MIGHTYMOUSE | 11 | Rodent superhero who sings "Here I come to save the day!": 2 wds. |
| 34% | MYLIFE | 6 | Billy Joel song with the line "I don't want you to tell me it's time to come home" (2 wds.) |
| 34% | IDID | 4 | Possible response to "Anyone do the readings?" |
| 34% | OKMOM | 5 | Possible response to "Go do the dishes!" |
| 34% | OLDME | 5 | Who I used to be, with "the" |
| 34% | THREEDOGNIGHT | 13 | Band with the 1970 #1 hit "Mama Told Me Not to Come": 3 wds. |
| 34% | VIOLA | 5 | With 28-Across, "How to Get Away with Murder" actress who wrote the 2022 memoir "Finding Me" |
| 34% | ARENT | 5 | "___ you the guy who tried to / Hurt me with the word goodbye?" (Dua Lipa lyric) |
| 33% | SAYITISNTSODA | 13 | Skeptical response to "Here's the drink I owe you"? |
| 33% | ALL | 3 | "This is to a girl who got into my head with ___ the pretty things she did" |