| 100% | INDULGENCES | 11 | Practice condemned in the "Ninety-Five Theses" |
| 47% | MULDER | 6 | Fox on Fox, in the nineties |
| 46% | FALSEIDOL | 9 | Its worship is condemned in the Bible |
| 46% | VCHIP | 5 | Parental-control device introduced in the nineties |
| 46% | POGS | 4 | Bottle-cap game popular in the nineties |
| 46% | SHAG | 4 | Practice casually in the outfield |
| 45% | ONCD | 4 | How many mixtapes were distributed in the nineties |
| 45% | ONCDS | 5 | How much music was sold in the nineties |
| 45% | ORLON | 5 | Acrylic fibre discontinued by DuPont in the nineties |
| 45% | SPAR | 4 | Practice jabs in the boxing ring |
| 44% | WITTENBERG | 10 | City where the "Ninety-Five Theses" were written |
| 44% | ALLSAINTSCHURCH | 15 | Building where the "Ninety-Five Theses" were posted |
| 44% | ISLAM | 5 | Five Pillars of ___ (foundational practices in the Muslim faith) |
| 43% | SPAR | 4 | Practice in the ring |
| 43% | SPARS | 5 | Practices in the ring |
| 43% | SELES | 5 | Monica who made thirteen Grand Slam singles finals in the nineties |
| 43% | TCI | 3 | Cable co. that merged with A.T. & T. in the nineties |
| 43% | TOES | 4 | What's in the five longest answers |
| 43% | INFO | 4 | "Tips" found in the five longest answers |
| 43% | SCRUNCHIES | 10 | Bands popular in the eighties and nineties |
| 43% | SPAR | 4 | Practice in the boxing ring |
| 43% | EARLY | 5 | Five in the morning, say |
| 43% | ENS | 3 | Five in the ninth inning? |
| 42% | SPARS | 5 | Practices in the boxing ring |
| 42% | SPARRING | 8 | Practicing in the boxing ring |
| 42% | PROTESTANT | 10 | With 24-Across, movement resulting from the "Ninety-Five Theses" |
| 42% | MOESHA | 6 | TV daughter of Frank Mitchell, in the nineties and early two-thousands |
| 42% | AOL | 3 | Internet company estimated to have mailed millions of CDs in the nineties |
| 42% | STARSEARCH | 10 | TV show on which Billy Porter and Usher appeared in the nineties |
| 42% | SPA | 3 | Resort hidden in the five longest puzzle answers |