| 100% | BALAAM | 6 | Prophet whose donkey scolded him |
| 47% | BALAAM | 6 | Old Testament character whose donkey spoke to him |
| 37% | HOSEA | 5 | Prophet whose name means "salvation" |
| 37% | HOSEA | 5 | Prophet whose name means "deliverance" |
| 35% | MICAH | 5 | Prophet whose name sounds like a mineral |
| 32% | AMOS | 4 | Old Testament prophet whose book comes before Obadiah |
| 31% | ELIJAH | 6 | Biblical prophet whose name means "Yahweh is my God" |
| 30% | HOSEA | 5 | Hebrew prophet whose Bible book is between Daniel and Joel |
| 30% | ISLAM | 5 | Religion whose primary prophet is Muhammad |
| 29% | OBADIAH | 7 | Hebrew prophet whose book of the Old Testament condemns the Edomites |
| 29% | JOSHUA | 6 | He replaced Moses as the prophet of the Israelites |
| 29% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Wooden boy whose nose tattles on him |
| 29% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Puppet whose nose grows when he lies |
| 29% | MICAH | 5 | Hebrew minor prophet whose Old Testament book foretells the destruction of Samaria |
| 28% | MIDAS | 5 | He was given the ears of a donkey, in myth |
| 28% | EDDIEMURPHY | 11 | He voiced Donkey in the 1-Across films: 2 wds. |
| 28% | ZOROASTER | 9 | Persian prophet with a religion named after him |
| 28% | BURRITO | 7 | Tortilla-wrapped item whose name means "little donkey" |
| 28% | BALAAM | 6 | Old Testament character whose ass spoke to him |
| 28% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Fictional character whose nose grows when he lies |
| 28% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Wooden puppet whose nose grows when he lies |
| 27% | LEHI | 4 | Mormon prophet, or the Utah city named for him |
| 27% | THEMARTIAN | 10 | Sci-fi hit whose tagline is "Bring him home" |
| 27% | CARGOCULT | 9 | Group whose prophets foresee the coming of material wealth |
| 27% | SPELT | 5 | ''Thrice happy he whose name has been well __'': Byron |
| 27% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Puppet whose nose grows when he tells a lie |
| 26% | EROS | 4 | God whose name sounds almost like the ammunition he uses |
| 26% | NINA | 4 | Hirschfeld's daughter, whose name he hid in his drawings |
| 26% | EROS | 4 | Greek god whose name sounds like the things he shoots |
| 26% | ELIOT | 5 | Poet whose friends called him "Tom" |