| 100% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "I, Tonya" |
| 91% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in the title "I, Tonya" |
| 80% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "Honey, I Shrunk the Kids" |
| 69% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark seen in "I, Too" |
| 65% | DOT | 3 | Punctuation mark in a URL |
| 65% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in a list |
| 65% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "1,000" |
| 64% | DOT | 3 | Punctuation mark in an email address |
| 64% | DOT | 3 | Punctuation mark in a Web address |
| 64% | DOT | 3 | Punctuation mark in every email address |
| 63% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "good-looking" |
| 63% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "two-faced" |
| 63% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in a list of items |
| 62% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "Get a Life, Chloe Brown" |
| 62% | COMMA | 5 | Unnecessary punctuation mark in, this clue |
| 60% | APOSTROPHE | 10 | Punctuation mark in the "Paradise City" rock band's name |
| 60% | SLASH | 5 | Punctuation mark often spoken in conversation |
| 59% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark separating items in a list |
| 59% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark seen in very large numbers |
| 59% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark used in this clue, appropriately |
| 59% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that usually appear in lists |
| 58% | HYPHENS | 7 | Pair of punctuation marks in the word "merry-go-round" |
| 58% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes eyes in an emoticon |
| 58% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark that separates words in many lists |
| 58% | SLASH | 5 | Punctuation mark that represents a spare in bowling |
| 58% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark representing the eyes in an emoticon |
| 57% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the "What's My Age Again?" rock band's name |
| 57% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that forms the eyes in many emoticons |
| 57% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that usually appear in a long list |
| 57% | HYPHENS | 7 | Punctuation marks seen in "know-how" and "far-fetched" |