| 100% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark representing the eyes in an emoticon |
| 70% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes eyes in an emoticon |
| 59% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that forms the eyes in many emoticons |
| 52% | NOSE | 4 | What the hyphen in an emoticon represents |
| 52% | NOSE | 4 | What the hyphen in an emoticon often represents |
| 46% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that may form an emoticon's "eyes" |
| 45% | LYIN | 4 | Like the eyes in an Eagles song title |
| 43% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes emoticon eyes |
| 43% | EYE | 3 | What a dot in an emoticon may represent |
| 43% | DOT | 3 | Punctuation mark in an email address |
| 42% | SEMICOLON | 9 | It makes up the eyes in a winking emoticon |
| 42% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "good-looking" |
| 42% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the word "two-faced" |
| 42% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in the title "I, Tonya" |
| 42% | SLASH | 5 | Punctuation mark that represents a spare in bowling |
| 42% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark in "Honey, I Shrunk the Kids" |
| 41% | APOSTROPHE | 10 | Punctuation mark in the "Paradise City" rock band's name |
| 40% | BLINK | 5 | In the __ of an eye; instantly |
| 40% | BLINK | 5 | In the ___ of an eye (quickly) |
| 40% | PERIOD | 6 | Punctuation mark placed at the end of a sentence or an abbreviation. |
| 39% | HYPHENS | 7 | Pair of punctuation marks in the word "merry-go-round" |
| 39% | HYPHEN | 6 | Punctuation mark in the "What's My Age Again?" rock band's name |
| 38% | EYES | 4 | What a colon usually represents in an emoticon |
| 38% | ALLATONCE | 9 | In the blink of an eye |
| 38% | RAPIDLY | 7 | In the blink of an eye |
| 38% | SOON | 4 | In the blink of an eye? |
| 37% | EYES | 4 | What a colon represents in an emoticon |
| 36% | SMILE | 5 | ), in an emoticon |
| 36% | FROWN | 5 | What a left parenthesis suggests in an emoticon |
| 35% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark represented by two dots |