| 100% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that may form an emoticon's "eyes" |
| 66% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes eyes in an emoticon |
| 65% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that forms the eyes in many emoticons |
| 57% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes emoticon eyes |
| 53% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark representing the eyes in an emoticon |
| 48% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that may give you pause? |
| 45% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark that might appear many times in a long list of words |
| 41% | SNARK | 5 | Comments that may come with an eye roll |
| 41% | SEND | 4 | Button that may submit an online form |
| 41% | SIGH | 4 | Sound that might accompany an eye roll |
| 40% | DASH | 4 | Punctuation mark that's longer than a hyphen |
| 40% | FUEL | 4 | *Gas station purchase that might be marked with an OCTane rating |
| 39% | DELI | 4 | Adding “sh” to its end forms an adjective that might describe its offerings |
| 37% | AGENDA | 6 | Guide that may form the outline for a meeting's minutes |
| 37% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that indicate pauses |
| 36% | PERIODS | 7 | Punctuation marks that end most sentences |
| 36% | DASH | 4 | Punctuation mark that looks like a hyphen |
| 36% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark that suggests a brief pause |
| 36% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that usually appear in lists |
| 36% | BULLET | 6 | Mark that may precede a 39-Across |
| 36% | SCAR | 4 | Mark that may be emotional or physical |
| 35% | DASH | 4 | Punctuation mark that looks like a long hyphen |
| 35% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark that separates words in many lists |
| 35% | SLASH | 5 | Punctuation mark that represents a spare in bowling |
| 35% | SCAR | 4 | Mark that may be covered by a tattoo |
| 35% | SMUDGE | 6 | Mark that might be left with greasy fingers |
| 35% | STAIN | 5 | Dirty mark that might require detergent |
| 35% | COMMAS | 6 | Punctuation marks that usually appear in a long list |
| 34% | DAM | 3 | Structure that may form a 55-Down |
| 34% | DOT | 3 | Mark that tops an ''i'' |